• Sweden edition
 

Manga images 'not child porn': police expert

Published: 15 May 2012 11:50 GMT+02:00
Updated: 15 May 2012 11:50 GMT+02:00

Björn Sellström, a criminal inspector of the National Bureau of Investigation (Rikskriminalen) at the agency's child porn unit, has taken the opportunity to speak out about the problems with concentrating on cartoons while there are everyday risks of the “real” thing in Sweden.

He fears that if the suspected man, Simon Lundström, is convicted, it will change the face of how police proceedings take place.

“I am doubtful of how a conviction would benefit those children who are actually suffering from real abuse which is being documented,” he wrote in the Svenska Dagbladet newspaper.

“Those children who are victims of documented abuse deserve more than to be put in the same category as these ‘human-like creatures’,” he wrote in the paper.

Lundström was found to be in possession some 52 pornographic images on his computer.

However, Sellström has argued that the so-called “manga” images do not constitute porn, as the fantasy characters are not even completely humanoid – let alone children.

The inspector wrote that investigators need a shift in focus towards the real instances of abuse and porn, and argued that time and money were being wasted chasing manga while children were continually suffering.

The trial begins at the Supreme Court on Wednesday.

The Local/og (news@thelocal.se)

Your comments about this article

14:59 May 15, 2012 by karex
Agree with Mr. Sellström, wasting public funds on investigating cartoons when real children are suffering is an insult.
20:44 May 15, 2012 by bcterry
Any interest in child porn should be dealt with seriously. even cartoons, which show a propensity towards this kind of behavior.
20:59 May 15, 2012 by LL2423
#2 - If I play video games that involve shooting people, does that mean I will eventually go out and perform those actions in real life? Because that's the exact mentality that you're implying here.
21:12 May 15, 2012 by bcterry
#2, would you be comfortable leaving him alone with your children if you knew he showed an interest by having those cartoons?

Your video game comparison is apples and oranges, a completely different matter than a sexual interest towards innocent children.
21:26 May 15, 2012 by LL2423
#4 - It's not different as it's the exact same mentality. Showing a "normal" person images depicting fictional children performing sexual acts would not negatively affect them at all, other than possibly offending them.

If any type of medium influences you to perform an actual crime, there's something wrong with you as an individual, not the medium itself.
22:02 May 15, 2012 by bcterry
" Showing a "normal" person images depicting fictional children performing sexual acts would not negatively affect them at all, other than possibly offending them."

He wasn't "shown" the images, he had them on his computer.

They didn't magically appear out of nowhere.

IF, and that's a BIG IF, they did just appear out of nowhere, he had the option of deleting, which apparently must have slipped his mind.
22:10 May 15, 2012 by LL2423
I was referring to an entirely hypothetical situation, completely unrelated to Simon's case. And it has been stated before that Simon didn't seek out content like this exclusively, he mostly batch-downloaded a bunch of images without properly looking at them, if I remember correctly. Obviously "I didn't look before downloading" doesn't hold up in court, but hey, it shows that he wasn't actively looking for content like this.

Riddle me this, if you will: who has Simon harmed by being in possession of these images? Has any child suffered as a result? Should Simon be grouped together with people who actually rape children or produce child pornography?
09:12 May 16, 2012 by Mxzf
Simon collected all Manga images and comics he could get his hands on. A handful out of some 100,000 more or less unsorted images does not constitute 'show a propensity towards this kind of behavior'.

Also, if 'show a propensity towards this kind of behavior' is a problem - the action should not be prison, but healthcare. We should in that case probably test everyone for 'propensity' when they get 18, and just put everyone with 'propensity' in forced hospital care (asylums?) until they stop, is that what you meant?
14:55 May 16, 2012 by bcterry
If he had those images, and knew what they were, IMO, he should have deleted them immediately.

I know one thing, if they showed up on my computer they would be gone in a heartbeat.

What logical reason would anyone have to keep this in their files, other than the obvious?
20:27 May 16, 2012 by LL2423
Have you researched this case at all? Simon is a professional manga translator - his line of work requires him to have extensive knowledge within that specific field, and that includes erotic content as well.

And, as stated before, Simon genuinely had no idea that these images could get him into trouble. No sane person would put fictional child pornography and real child pornography in the same category. That's ridiculously insulting to the hundreds of thousands of children around the world who have been exploited sexually.

Since you didn't answer my previous question, I'll ask again. Who has Simon harmed? Who is the supposed victim in this case? Do you honestly think that the police should use their already limited resources to arrest people like Simon instead of going after actual pedophiles?
20:31 May 16, 2012 by bcterry
Since you didn't answer my previous question, I'll ask again. Who has Simon harmed? Who is the supposed victim in this case? Do you honestly think that the police should use their already limited resources to arrest people like Simon instead of going after actual pedophiles? "

Happy to address your question, but as you avoided my first question, let's take care of that first and then we'll go from there.

"would you feel comfortable with leaving your children alone with him if you knew he had those images filed on his computer?"
20:44 May 16, 2012 by LL2423
I would have no problem with that, at all. Real children and manga "children" have clear aesthetical differences (do I really even need to point this out), and there's plenty of "pedophiles" out there who keep their attraction limited to fictional entities.

The way I see it, there are two types of pedophiles: passive pedophiles and aggressive pedophiles. Passive pedophiles are the ones who are against child pornography (these people really exist, do some research) and would never ever exploit a child. Aggressive pedophiles are the ones who actually commit crimes. Despite their clear differences, they're grouped together because of this nonsensical law.

Of course it might be hard to judge who's aggressive and who's passive, but just looking at fictional images on the internet should not get you arrested. I'm done, now please answer my question.
21:24 May 16, 2012 by bcterry
I would have no problem with that, at all. Real children and manga "children" have clear aesthetical differences (do I really even need to point this out), and there's plenty of "pedophiles" out there who keep their attraction limited to fictional entities."

That's where we part company, i would never leave my child alone with any pedophile, passive or not.

Who has he harmed, i don't know, and i doubt you don't know as well.

Who is the victim in this case, no one i know of, but those who are attracted to these images may be stimulated by them to act out on a real child.

As i stated in my first post, any interest in child porn should be looked at seriously by the police, and if it leads to criminal activity, such as other images of real children, then they should be arrested, and prosecuted.

Limited resources should not be a factor when it comes the abuse of children, and i'm sure that what it takes to look into these situations is not a tremendous drain on those resources.
21:32 May 16, 2012 by LL2423
The difference here is that possessing fictional (read: not real) images of fictional children carrying out a fictional scenario is on an entirely different level than real children being exploited.

I'm entirely against the concept of child pornography, don't get me wrong, but I hardly constitute these images to be child pornography, as they depict children in a completely non-realistic manner. I still believe that it is entirely possible to be a fan of manga-style artwork without having an urge to sexually exploit kids (if this wasn't already obvious enough).

A person should not be prosecuted because of their fantasies, or for researching the fantasies of others. Last time I checked, freedom of expression was a part of the Swedish constitution. Having exceptions within such a law just destroys its purpose entirely.
22:44 May 16, 2012 by bcterry
"A person should not be prosecuted because of their fantasies, or for researching the fantasies of others. Last time I checked, freedom of expression was a part of the Swedish constitution. Having exceptions within such a law just destroys its purpose entirely. "

Where did i say he should be prosecuted for his fantasies or even these images?

Read what i said specifically.

"'m entirely against the concept of child pornography, don't get me wrong, but I hardly constitute these images to be child pornography, as they depict children in a completely non-realistic manner."

Have you seen these pictures?

If not, how do you know they depict children in a non-realistic manner?
23:45 May 16, 2012 by LL2423
"People" in manga-style artwork look different than real people. This is not merely a subjective opinion, this is a fact. Some of the images that Simon was intially prosecuted for were later considered "not inappropriate", and thus totally legal to view and download in Sweden. These are the images that I'm basing my arguments off of, but they apply to all other images as well, regardless of how "hardcore" they are. Nothing that is drawn and fictional should be considered illegal, period.
12:52 May 17, 2012 by jackjones
Cartoons imply no interest in real child porn. By the same logic, does that mean that people who watch crime dramas are "interested" in actually robbing banks? If you watch war films, does that make you a genocidal maniac? Of course not.

People should learn to differentiate fantasy from reality... kids learn how to, when they are about 2 years old, you would think adults would know better..
14:09 May 17, 2012 by bcterry
ANY depiction of an adult having sex with a child, even if it's stick men, is sick and perverted, .... period!

" By the same logic, does that mean that people who watch crime dramas are "interested" in actually robbing banks? If you watch war films, does that make you a genocidal maniac? Of course not."

If you cannot make a distinction between crime dramas and sex with children, in any form, well .....................................
15:53 May 17, 2012 by LL2423
"ANY depiction of an adult having sex with a child, even if it's stick men, is sick and perverted, .... period!"

This is merely your own personal subjective opinion. I find a lot of things disgusting myself, however I don't have anything against the people who enjoy those types of content.

Your argument is entirely fueled by moral panic. Please try to view this situation from an objective and unbiased standpoint, rather than sticking to your idea of what's "right" and what's "wrong".
19:04 May 17, 2012 by bcterry
"Your argument is entirely fueled by moral panic."

Moral panic?, .........LOL, please.

I could respond in kind about your moral position, but it speaks for itself.

"Please try to view this situation from an objective and unbiased standpoint, rather than sticking to your idea of what's "right" and what's "wrong".

My stand point on the sexual abuse of children is not open to "unbiased objectivity" , and i dare say it is in total lockstep with well over 90% of the population.

"I don't have anything against the people who enjoy those types of content."

That is MORE than apparent.

See ya.
19:31 May 17, 2012 by LL2423
So let me summarize this: you believe that it is entirely fair to arrest people over crimes that have no victims, and to put this action on the same priority as arresting people who are actually committing real crimes towards children. Additionally, you believe that 90% of the Swedish population shares this opinion with you.

Just tell me if I'm right or wrong here.
21:45 May 17, 2012 by bcterry
"So let me summarize this: you believe that it is entirely fair to arrest people over crimes that have no victims, and to put this action on the same priority as arresting people who are actually committing real crimes towards children. Additionally, you believe that 90% of the Swedish population shares this opinion with you."

I was done here, but i will respond ONCE MORE to that question.

Do you not read what i have posted?

#13,

"As i stated in my first post, any interest in child porn should be looked at seriously by the police, and if, IF, it leads to criminal activity such as other images of real children, then they should be arrested, and prosecuted.

Limited resources should not be a factor when it comes the abuse of children, and i'm sure that what it takes to look into these situations is not a tremendous drain on those resources. "

And yes, i absolutely believe that 90% of Swedes would agree with that statement.

I also agree that 90% of Swedes would agree that ANY sort of depiction of adults having sexual relations with children is sick and perverted, whether or not anyone in possession of such material is arrested and charged.

I could care less, and have absolutely no problem with

what forms of sex that consenting adults engage in, but innocent children are OFF LIMITS!!!, and don't dare cross that line and expect to get away with it.

I'm from Canada, and damn proud of our laws on child pornography, and believe that all civilized countries will eventually get on board.

"Canadian law forbids the production, distribution, and possession of child pornography. Prohibitions cover visual representations of sexual activity by persons (real or imaginary) under the age of 18, depiction of their sexual organ/anal region for a sexual purpose, or any written material or visual representation that advocates child pornography offenses against a person under 18. There is an exception for material with artistic merit or an educational, scientific, or medical purpose. The law against simple possession of child pornography was declared void in British Columbia by a 1998 provincial court ruling but this decision was overturned two years later by the Canadian Supreme Court.[11] The high court further concluded that a "person" under the law could be either real or fictional and that the prohibition of written texts was potentially acceptable.[12][13] Cases have now been prosecuted in Canada involving anime and manga child pornography."
23:45 May 17, 2012 by LL2423
You might want to re-think that all Swedes agree with your statement. A quick run-through of all the comment sections of all the news sites that have published articles relevant to this case will prove this, as most people find the law itself to be absurd. And it's not just normal people who find this law unreasonable, law experts and even police officers have criticised this case, claiming that it's insulting to put fictional children and real children on the same level of priority.

Additionally, a quick Google search will show you just how perfect your biased Canadian "child porn" law is. Plenty of people have had comics and computers seized over images that were later deemed "not indecent". People have even had non-erotic manga seized just because "hey, it's from Japan, it absolutely _has_ to be indecent!". Even though they weren't charged, they were all still branded as pedophiles, and that's not a label that you want to live with.

Look up the Brandon X case, for example. He had two questionable items seized, was branded a pedophile, and thrown into custody. He was later freed (because the Canadian police finally realized that "hey, prosecuting someone over this is really goddamn stupid"), but he still has to live on with being labeled as a sex offender. I don't know how anyone can consider such a law to be even remotely fair.

Regardless, I'm done here, since it's quite obvious that I can't change your mind when it comes to this stuff. You don't even need to respond if you don't want to.
13:36 May 19, 2012 by tetrahedron
Has anyone actually seen these cartoons? It sounds to me like a bit of a fuss about nothing. What worries me more are the actual depictions of children being abused which can be accessed by the click of a few buttons on the computer. Sometimes these sites can be accessed by accident and it would not take the police long to find a number of such sites if they cared to look for them. So why aren't they closing all theses sites down? I think that there should be a serious international effort to stop this and it should be given a priority before any other form of organised crime except terrorism. If they spent as much time and money on this as they do on the so-called "war on drugs", it would probably do more good and, if all drugs were put under some sort of legal control, there would be more room in the prisons to give paedophiles longer sentences. There should be a war on paedophilia. It looks to me like they're only fighting a half-hearted battle at the moment.
Today's headlines
National
Anti-Israel graffiti 'not a race crime': Court
Photo: TT

Anti-Israel graffiti 'not a race crime': Court

A teenage boy who painted anti-Israel slogans and symbols on the Concert Hall in Gothenburg has been convicted for the damages he caused, but he walked free from racial agitation charges. READ  

Politics
'We knew that Israel would be critical'
Israeli ambassador Isaac Bachman. Photo: TT

'We knew that Israel would be critical'

UPDATED: Sweden's Foreign Minister has told The Local she respects Israel's decision to recall its ambassador from Stockholm, after Sweden officially recognized the State of Palestine. READ  

Entertainment
A closer look at Sweden's rising stars
Swedish actresses Sandra Huldt and Julia Ragnarsson. Julia (right) has been nominated for a Rising Star award. Photo: TT

A closer look at Sweden's rising stars

Like to be ahead of the game when it comes to the next big thing on the silver screen? We find out more about the Swedish nominees for the Rising Star award to be presented at Stockholm's International Film Festival next week. READ  

Science
Swedish women in two-year sex pill study
Contraceptive pills have been linked to mood swings. Photo: Shutterstock

Swedish women in two-year sex pill study

Three hundred women from across Sweden are taking part in a study designed to demonstrate that modern contraceptive pills don't lead to decreased libido or mood swings. READ  

National
Stockholm 'sinking' oil spill ship safe
The ship was rescued on Thursday. Photo: Swedish Coast Guard

Stockholm 'sinking' oil spill ship safe

After fears a ship carrying around 52 tonnes of oil could sink in Stockholm's archipelago, Sweden's Coast Guard said the vessel had been towed to safety. READ  

National
Dog attack policewoman acquitted on appeal
A scene from a video of the attack published by Dagens Nyheter

Dog attack policewoman acquitted on appeal

A policewoman accused of letting her dog attack a drunk man while she repeatedly hit him with a baton, has had her conviction overturned by a court in Stockholm. READ  

Entertainment
What's On: October 31st - November 7th
Uma Thurman will soon be on her way to Stockholm. Photo: TT

What's On: October 31st - November 7th

Halloween fun and an international film festival are the big events hitting Stockholm this week. We cast our eye over the capital and the rest of the country for the best activities to check out this week. READ  

International
Pirate Bay Swede found guilty in Denmark
Gottrid Svartholm Warg. File photo: TT

Pirate Bay Swede found guilty in Denmark

Sweden's Pirate Bay Founder Gottrid Svartholm Warg was found guilty of hacking crimes in a Danish court on Thursday. READ  

National
Malmö loses out as rare toads move in
The European green toad. Photo: H. Krisp (WikiCommons)

Malmö loses out as rare toads move in

After a rare species of toad moved into southern Sweden's Malmö, builders have had to tone down massive expansion plans in the area. READ  

Politics
Palestine recognized as state by Sweden
Sweden's Foreign Minister is Margot Wallström. Photo: TT

Palestine recognized as state by Sweden

The Swedish government has officially decided to recognize Palestine, with the move announced in a speech by the country's new Foreign Minister Margot Wallström. READ  

RECEIVE OUR NEWSLETTER AND ALERTS
Lifestyle
Stockholm's shocking take on Halloween
Sport
Top ten quotes from Zlatan Ibrahimovic
Business & Money
Get your own office in Gothenburg or Stockholm - free for a day
Gallery
People-watching: October 30th
National
Sweden remains fourth best for gender equality
Blog updates

31 October

Editor’s Blog, October 31st (The Local Sweden) »

"Hello readers, Welcome to our latest 60-second round-up of the week’s news. First, Sweden made headlines around the..." READ »

 

29 October

Scariest day (Blogweiser) »

"This is what’s frightening me on Halloween. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D4OFZVCu8J0&list=UUJu5J7jG4uoYSjWbpFsJBuQ Follow my posts on FB. ..." READ »

 
 
 
National
Timeline: Julian Assange sex allegations
Sport
World Cup ski race on 'fake' Stockholm slope
Society
An Arctic tradition: hunting and handicraft
Society
Stockholm taxis offer free therapy sessions
National
The Local meets Health Minister Gabriel Wikström
Gallery
Property of the week: Österåker
Society
Homeless turtles get Stockholm police ride
National
Construction worker has 'Sweden's best beard'
National
Italian musician jazzes up Sweden's Lapland
Gallery
Zlatan's career in pictures
Finest.se
Gallery
People-watching: October 25th and 26th
Lifestyle
'Swedes are funnier than they think'
National
Swedish town 'like Venice' after heavy rains
Lifestyle
What's On in Sweden: October 24th - 31st
Gallery
People-watching: October 22nd
Gallery
In Pictures: Prince Carl Philip and Sofia Hellqvist
Lifestyle
Eight things to love about renting a Swedish apartment
National
Vasa ship cannon blasted in Sweden
National
Sub hunt: Day-by-day
National
Sub hunt: Stockholm islanders share their fears with The Local
Sponsored Article
The best options for oversea transfers
National
Dentist gives free care to Roma beggars
Gallery
Property of the week: Malmö
Gallery
PHOTOS: 'Foreign activity' in Swedish waters
TT
Society
QUIZ: How good is your Swedish?
Society
The nudity... and nine other things expat men notice in Sweden
Gallery
People-watching: October 15th
Gallery
Your views: Should outdoor smoking be banned in Sweden?
Business & Money
Sweden has 'large hole' in finances
Sponsored Article
Introducing... Finding a job in Stockholm
Society
Monster salmon caught in northern Sweden
Gallery
Property of the week: Lorensberg
National
Scandinavia's child bride
National
Ebola crisis: How is Sweden preparing?
Business & Money
How Sweden is becoming a cashless society
Gallery
Stockholm Burlesque Festival 2014
National
How a little red horse became a symbol for Sweden
Gallery
People-watching: October 12th
Business & Money
The hottest start-ups from southern Sweden
National
Stockholm is 'best' region for well-being
Sponsored Article
How to catch the first lobster of the year
Team SCA
Sponsored Article
All-female SCA team takes off on Volvo Ocean Race
Latest news from The Local in Austria

More news from Austria at thelocal.at

Latest news from The Local in Switzerland

More news from Switzerland at thelocal.ch

Latest news from The Local in Germany

More news from Germany at thelocal.de

Latest news from The Local in Denmark

More news from Denmark at thelocal.dk

Latest news from The Local in Spain

More news from Spain at thelocal.es

Latest news from The Local in France

More news from France at thelocal.fr

Latest news from The Local in Italy

More news from Italy at thelocal.it

Latest news from The Local in Norway

More news from Norway at thelocal.no

970
jobs available
Swedish Down Town Consulting & Productions
Swedish Down Town Consulting & Productions is an innovative business company which provides valuable assistance with the Swedish Authorities, Swedish language practice and general communications. Call 073-100 47 81 or visit:
www.swedishdowntown.com
PSD Media
PSD Media is marketing company that offers innovative solutions for online retailers. We provide modern solutions that help increase traffic and raise conversion. Visit our site at:
http://psdmedia.se
If you want to drink, that’s your business.
If you want to stop, we can help.

Learn more about English-language Alcoholics Anonymous in Sweden. No dues. No fees. Confidentiality assured.
AA-EUROPE.ORG/SWEDEN