• Sweden edition
 
'Re-open probe into Raoul Wallenberg’s fate'

'Re-open probe into Raoul Wallenberg’s fate'

Published: 06 Jul 2012 13:10 GMT+02:00
Updated: 06 Jul 2012 13:10 GMT+02:00

Official claims from Russia about when Swedish diplomat Raoul Wallenberg died appear ever more doubtful as new evidence emerges, argues historian Susanne Berger, who has called for the investigation in Wallenberg's fate to be re-opened.

After conducting a decade-long investigation, the official joint Swedish-Russian Working Group studying Wallenberg's fate in Russia concluded its report in 2001 with these succinct words: "The burden of proof regarding the death of Raoul Wallenberg rests with the Russian government".

Eleven years later, the world is still waiting for that proof.

As Hans Magnusson, the former Chairman of the Swedish Working Group remarked in a speech in Moscow a few weeks ago, the idea that Wallenberg died on July 17th, 1947 “seems an increasingly shaky one.”

In January, Magnusson was appointed by Swedish Foreign Minister Carl Bildt to conduct a fact-finding mission to study what new information exists in the Wallenberg case and how it can be best followed up. Bildt took the step in response to growing complaints by researchers about the lack of direct access to Russian archives.

Swedish officials have known for decades that Russia has important records that it refuses to show. However, the Swedish government currently considers the Raoul Wallenberg case purely a historical issue and wants any remaining questions solved through “cooperative” archival research.

For researchers, this means that the Wallenberg inquiry is essentially moving in circles. They know exactly what documentation they need to see but cannot obtain the necessary official support from either Russian or Swedish officials to gain access to it.

Last September, the chief of the Russian State Security Service's (FSB) Archival Directorate, Lt. Gen. Vasily Khristoforov, emphasized in an interview with the Associated Press (AP) that he was “more than convinced that if Wallenberg outlived the official date of his death, it could only have been by a few days.”

However, Khristoforov offered no insight from what particular knowledge or documentation he derived this certainty.

A closer examination of all documentation currently available in the case shows that there is a surprisingly even split in evidence pointing towards the possible death of Raoul Wallenberg in July 1947 and that of his possible strict isolation at the time.

It was in fact Khristoforov and the FSB archives that have thrown the most serious doubt on the old Soviet version that Wallenberg died on July 17th, 1947.

In 2009, Khristoforov revealed that a Prisoner No. 7 who is believed to have been Raoul Wallenberg was interrogated on July 23rd, 1947, six days after what Russian officials have maintained is the date of Wallenberg's death.

What we do know for sure is that Raoul Wallenberg was questioned on March 11th, 1947 in Lubyanka prison.

From then on, he could have been either killed or continued to be held in Lubyanka, Lefortovo or another prison – most likely in or around Moscow – as a prisoner under investigation.

Another possibility is that Wallenberg was formally charged and sentenced for a crime and sent to a known isolation facility like those at the prisons of Vladimir, Verkhne Uralsk or Alexandrovsk.

Alternatively, he could have been transferred to a Special Camp or possibly a psychiatric hospital.

Regardless, some kind of decisive action was definitely taken on or around July 22nd or 23rd, 1947.

The absence of any independently corroborated witness testimonies about Raoul Wallenberg’s presence in the Soviet prison system after 1947 suggests that he may have died around that time, but the issue is far from clear.

“The inquiry into Wallenberg's death should be reopened,” argues Nikita Petrov, the deputy director of the human rights group ‘Memorial’ in Moscow.

As he told the Russian news agency Interfax on May 29th, “from my point of view, this could be a criminal inquiry. Murder is a criminal offense, and here it is important to identify all those responsible and reconstruct the picture of the crime."

Unlike Petrov, other Wallenberg experts do not believe it is certain that Wallenberg was killed in July 1947.

Important questions raised by Susan Mesinai, Dr. Marvin Makinen and Ari Kaplan, the former independent consultants to the Swedish-Russian Working Group, regarding the numbering of highly secret foreign prisoners in Soviet captivity remain unanswered.

In her report from 2001, Mesinai pointed out that the chronological numbering of about thirty sentenced prisoners held in Vladimir between the years 1947-1952 shows obvious gaps.

In fact, for the years 1947-48 – the most critical period of the Wallenberg case – six numbers remain unidentified.

It is possible that one of these numbers was assigned to Raoul Wallenberg, Mesinai writes.

And Russian authorities still have not identified an unknown Swedish prisoner held in Vladimir Prison during the 1950s and early 1960s. The answer to this simple question alone could move the case dramatically forward.

While some experts stress that Soviet leader Joseph Stalin would have had little use for Raoul Wallenberg after 1947, others dispute that assertion.

As the Swedish Working Group Report suggests, the killing of a foreign diplomat was a very serious matter.

"Although we know that Stalin had few, if any, moral scruples," the report argues, "it would have been exceptional to order the execution of a diplomat from a neutral country. It might have appeared simpler to keep him in isolation."

In other words, Stalin may have wanted to gauge if Wallenberg could not be of some use to him in the months or years ahead.

But key Russian intelligence files that could provide insight into the Soviet leadership’s thinking on this issue remain firmly classified in Russian archives.

How long could Raoul Wallenberg have survived?

That question is currently impossible to answer. The official Soviet notification of Wallenberg's death to the Swedish government from February 1957 raises doubts that he was alive beyond that time.

However, investigators continue to wonder why Soviet officials at that moment offered such an ambiguous account of his alleged death and why Russian officials have not provided a fuller explanation of Wallenberg's fate since then.

It appears very unlikely at this stage that the current Russian leadership does not know what happened to Raoul Wallenberg.

High level institutional memory was available until very recently and to some degree remains available today.

Sergei Kartashov, head of the Fourth Department, Third Main Directorate of MGB that investigated Raoul Wallenberg's case in 1947, died in 1979.

Anastas Mikoyan, a longtime member of the Politburo, survived until 1978; long-time Soviet Foreign Minister Vyacheslav Molotov was still alive in 1986 while Nikolai Selivanovsky, Deputy to Minister of State Security Viktor Abakumov who had direct authority over Wallenberg’s case, died only in 1997.

Two of Raoul Wallenberg's interrogators, Danil Kopelyanksy and his colleague Boris Solovov, lived past the year 2000.

According to Nikita Petrov, there is little doubt that Russian authorities are continuing to conceal important documentation. As he told Interfax, “there is a bulk of evidence which is gradually coming to the surface...This gives us reasons to suggest that not everything was investigated in the Wallenberg case."

Arseny Roginsky, co-founder of Russia-based human rights group ‘Memorial’, shares this assessment.

"Is it possible to clarify the Wallenberg case? Yes, it is possible," Roginsky said in a recent interview, adding that this requires "free independent researchers working in Russian archives.”

But direct access to key documentation continues to be the core problem in a country where independent historical review finds itself under increasing pressure. In 2009, Mikhail Suprun, a respected Professor of History at Pomorsky State University in Archangelsk, was arrested while researching the fate of ethnic Germans in the Soviet Union during World War II.

The charges concerned alleged violation of Russian privacy laws. The official who provided him with the files, Alexander Dudarev, Head of the Information Centre of the Arkhangelsk Regional Ministry of Internal Affairs, was also arrested.

In December 2011 the case against Suprun was dropped. Dudarev, however, received a one year suspended sentence. Suprun meanwhile has been forced to leave his academic post and his documents as well as his computer have been confiscated by the Russian Federal Security Service (FSB).

The files Suprun studied – personal and investigative files of former prisoners in the Soviet penal system – are precisely the type of documentation researchers need to review in the Wallenberg case.

The arrests of Suprun and Dudarev will undoubtedly have a discouraging effect on both historians and Russian archivists who now must weigh the wish of accommodating research requests with the potentially serious risks involved in providing access to sensitive historical records

The simplest explanation for why the Russian government does not release the full facts about the Raoul Wallenberg case is that the truth does not fit with the decades old Soviet version of his fate.

The Kremlin may feel that revelation of the truth about Raoul Wallenberg runs counter to its current policy of promoting only "useful" history, the presentation of historical events in ways that serve to reinforce President Vladimir Putin's idea of a strong, powerful Russia.

It is time to be daring and to face the possible contradictions - the world and Raoul Wallenberg's family have been waiting far too long.

Susanne Berger is a US-based German historian heavily involved in research into the life of Raoul Wallenberg, the Swedish diplomat who helped prevent the arrests of thousands of Hungarian Jews during the Second World War.

Don't miss...X
Left Right

Your comments about this article

15:51 July 7, 2012 by motti
Let us all hope that the Swedish administration will have the courage to really push the Russians for a full explanation. I doubt that this will happen, after all, so many years have gone by without the top Swedish echelon really showing any interest. This in itself is appallingly evident and shameful.

This brave, decent humanist deserves better, certainly from his own country. I just wonder that if he had been trying to save German SS troops from understandably Russian vengeance, whether the Swedish lite would have acted any differently?
20:10 July 8, 2012 by nukeiran
ooh, a little bit harsh motti.
10:33 July 9, 2012 by krattan
Considering the amount of praise this guy gets from NATO countries he was probably a spy. Maybe in a 100 years we will find out. I'm sure information about his late circumstances is not only hidden in Russia but in Sweden as well.
16:46 July 9, 2012 by DAVID T
I wonder how much the decade-long investigation cost the Swedish tax payers - He's dead - get over it
17:17 July 9, 2012 by guliver
He is dead but he desrve to be brought to his last way as an hero.

I wish my country would have done more to realizze that.it is possibile.

Israel
13:17 July 10, 2012 by jostein
Id rather see a probe into that gold he was "taking care of".
17:20 July 10, 2012 by guliver
Jostein

Everybody sees its side-you see gold ,I see the poor people he saved from their certain death and still live among us.
12:38 July 11, 2012 by jostein
Yea, i guess you are right. Who can blame him for making a little bit on the side? He did help alot of people.
17:09 July 13, 2012 by RobinHood
@Jostein

Please would you present your evidence for your "making a little bit on the side" jibe.

You are going to look an awfully big fool if you can't.
18:59 July 13, 2012 by guliver
Jostein

I do not care if the man got money or gold for saving Jews.

I care about those who went to the Gestapo got money just to indicate where the Jews hiding,and there were much more from this type then Raul Wallenberg type.
22:18 July 13, 2012 by cogito
Wallenbergare with mashed postatoes and peas is my favorite Swedish dish
12:52 July 14, 2012 by guliver
Cognito

Here you give the answer from one hand why nobody make effort to respect him and to find out what happened to him ,and from other hand how could the German kill so many millions of innocent people ,while the public closed his eyes and cover his ears.
16:16 July 14, 2012 by johnny1939
Let Wallenberg rest in peace nothing will be accomplished by chewing his fate over and over what difference does it make. After all the Russians are our friends now along w/ the Germans and the Japanese.
11:40 July 18, 2012 by rise
#13

"After all the Russians are our friends now...]"

HA! Ivan has always done as he please and will continue doing exactly that. Ivan isn't "friend" with anyone, nor has he been in a thousand years.
16:06 July 25, 2012 by AllaR
"The Kremlin may feel that revelation of the truth about Raoul Wallenberg runs counter to its current policy of promoting only "useful" history, the presentation of historical events in ways that serve to reinforce President Vladimir Putin's idea of a strong, powerful Russia" - Pff...this is a usual story that a US-based German writer can say....sounds like a copy-paste abstract.
Today's headlines
Police seeking missing Swede in London
Sofie Marie Jansson, who is currently missing in London. Photo: Metropolitan Police

Police seeking missing Swede in London

British police have issued a plea for tips in the search to find Swedish national Sofie Marie Jansson who hasn't been seen for almost a week. READ () »

University applications rocket to record high

University applications rocket to record high

Swedish universities continue to draw vast amounts of applicants with the number of prospective students seeking a third level education increasing for the seventh year in a row. READ () »

Man jailed in US over Lars Vilks murder plot
Swedish artist Lars Vilks pictured in New York in 2012. Photo: Linus Sundahl-Djerf/TT

Man jailed in US over Lars Vilks murder plot

American authorities have sentenced a 20-year-old accomplice of 'Jihad Jane' to five years in prison for an attempted terror plot to kill Swedish artist Lars Vilks, after getting involved with the murder plans when he was a teenager. READ () »

Sweden scraps 'new start zones' after EU input
Integration Minister Erik Ullenhag visits a school in Tensta, one of the neighbourhoods mentioned when he and his colleagues first floated the new start zone proposal. File: TT

Sweden scraps 'new start zones' after EU input

Sweden has abandoned a plan to ease taxes for small companies in blighted areas after the European Commission challenged its legality. READ () »

'Easter eggs an invitation to spread germs'
A typical Swedish Easter egg. Photo: Jessica Gow/TT

'Easter eggs an invitation to spread germs'

A Swedish microbiologist has warned that traditional Swedish Easter eggs laden with candy are an open invitation to the spread of bacteria and viruses. "Is this really a good idea?" he asked. READ () »

Jammed truck snarls Stockholm rush hour
Photo: Anders Wiklund/TT

Jammed truck snarls Stockholm rush hour

PICTURES: A truck got wedged inside a tunnel in central Stockholm on Thursday, with authorities concerned the accident may have damaged cables in the tunnel's ceiling. READ () »

Kids in Victorian garb mark Swedish Easter
A Swedish Easter witch holding daffodils. File photo: TT

Kids in Victorian garb mark Swedish Easter

In India, I'd notice Easter only from the traffic jam outside the churches, but here witches, egg hunts, and feathers mark the Christian holiday. The Local's Deepti Vashisht brings you the various shades of Swedish Easter. READ () »

Swedish MP ordered chemtrail probe
Chemtrails?: Shutterstock.

Swedish MP ordered chemtrail probe

A Swedish MP who launched an official government investigation into the existence of chemtrails tells The Local why he thinks Swedes deserve the truth, even if it may leave some conspiracy theorists unsatisfied. READ () »

PM pleads ignorance of Vattenfall's Nuon bid
Fredrik Reinfeldt answers the constitutional affairs committee's questions. Photo: TT

PM pleads ignorance of Vattenfall's Nuon bid

Sweden's prime minister on Thursday said Vattenfall itself, not its owners the Swedish state, had responsibility for the loss-making Nuon deal. READ () »

'Kockums submarine raid may be illegal': lawyer
Photo: TT

'Kockums submarine raid may be illegal': lawyer

A Swedish lawyer says the Swedish military may have broken the law when it raided the Malmö premises of German defence giant Thyssen Krupp. READ () »

RECEIVE OUR NEWSLETTER AND ALERTS
Society
Swedish supermarket Ica pulls contested Easter commercial off air
Kungahuset
Society
Swedish royals set baptism date for princess
finest.se
Gallery
People-watching April 16
Politics
Who's the prime minister's heir?
Alfie Atkins
Society
Are children's books the key to families integrating in Sweden?
National
'Sweden Dem protests cater to party's martyr image'
National
'Swedish research grants were fantastic, but now it's like Australia'
Society
Only in Sweden: The ten problems you'd never encounter elsewhere
National
Swedes stopped to take my picture, but didn't look me in the eyes
Business & Money
A swipe of the hand replaced cash and cards in Lund
YouTube
Features
Video: Oliver Gee finds out how to embrace The Swedish Hug
TT
National
Abba duo hints at reunion
Advertisement:
Private
National
Flash mobs hug it out across Sweden
Finest.se
Gallery
People-watching April 11-13
TT
Politics
Swedes to give six-hour workday a go
TT
Society
Aussie choir member wows Abba in Sweden
YouTube
Society
Stockholm magic a surprise YouTube hit
Fastighetsbyrån
Society
Gallery: The Local's Property of the Week
Private
Society
Swedes find 200-year-old gravestone in living room
Stockholm School of Economics
Sponsored Article
Why a bachelor's degree is no longer enough
Deepti Vashisht
Features
Deepti Vashisht dissects the magic of Sweden's personal ID number
Shutterstock
Society
Ten signs you've been in Sweden too long
Society
Jimi Fritze heard every word when doctors discussed taking his organs
Society
A Swedish farmer explains why the new bestiality ban is 'pointless'
ESL
Sponsored Article
Learning Swedish the easy way
Latest news from The Local in Switzerland

More news from Switzerland at thelocal.ch

Latest news from The Local in Germany

More news from Germany at thelocal.de

Latest news from The Local in Spain

More news from Spain at thelocal.es

Latest news from The Local in France

More news from France at thelocal.fr

Latest news from The Local in Italy

More news from Italy at thelocal.it

Latest news from The Local in Norway

More news from Norway at thelocal.no

Blog Update: The Diplomatic Dispatch

28 October 15:16

The Green Growth Group Summit »

"Today on the 28 October in Brussels, a large group of key EU Ministers and business people, including UK Secretary of State for Energy and Climate Change Edward Davey, and Swedish Environment Minister Lena Ek, will meet to discuss green growth. They all have a stake in resolving a challenge which, although it is crucial..." READ »

762
jobs available
Swedish Down Town Consulting & Productions
Swedish Down Town Consulting & Productions is an innovative business company which provides valuable assistance with the Swedish Authorities, Swedish language practice and general communications. Call 073-100 47 81 or visit:
www.swedishdowntown.com