Spyker, Saab lawsuit rejected by GM
US carmaker General Motors has denied any criminal wrongdoing in the bankruptcy of Swedish carmaker Saab, calling on US authorities to throw out a lawsuit filed by Dutch carmaker Spyker which is seeking $3 billion in damages.
The lawsuit, filed in early August, charges GM criminally interfered in an operation that could have made it possible for Saab to restructure and stay afloat, because the US automaker wanted to dominate the Chinese market.
Saab, a former GM subsidiary, filed for bankruptcy in December after teetering on the edge of the abyss for almost two years. A last-ditch bid to raise funds in China, with the group Youngman, was nixed by GM over technology transfer issues.
In a document filed Friday in US District Court in Michigan, GM denied any criminal action or intent.
"Saab had granted GM a contractual right to consent or to withhold its consent to the transaction plaintiffs proposed," it said.
"In fact, all GM is alleged to have done is publicly express its lack of support for plaintiffs' last-ditch proposal. That conduct cannot constitute improper interference as a matter of law."
GM sold Saab in 2010 to Spyker. A deal reached parallel to the sale allowed Saab to keep using GM technologies to keep production going, but allowed GM to stop the arrangement if Saab changed hands.
"Spyker bought Saab knowing this financial history, and subject to terms spelled out unambiguously in the agreements attached to the complaint. Those agreements included clear contractual limitations on the future use of GM's technology, and on the transfer of that technology to others," the GM filing stressed.
Comments
See Also
The lawsuit, filed in early August, charges GM criminally interfered in an operation that could have made it possible for Saab to restructure and stay afloat, because the US automaker wanted to dominate the Chinese market.
Saab, a former GM subsidiary, filed for bankruptcy in December after teetering on the edge of the abyss for almost two years. A last-ditch bid to raise funds in China, with the group Youngman, was nixed by GM over technology transfer issues.
In a document filed Friday in US District Court in Michigan, GM denied any criminal action or intent.
"Saab had granted GM a contractual right to consent or to withhold its consent to the transaction plaintiffs proposed," it said.
"In fact, all GM is alleged to have done is publicly express its lack of support for plaintiffs' last-ditch proposal. That conduct cannot constitute improper interference as a matter of law."
GM sold Saab in 2010 to Spyker. A deal reached parallel to the sale allowed Saab to keep using GM technologies to keep production going, but allowed GM to stop the arrangement if Saab changed hands.
"Spyker bought Saab knowing this financial history, and subject to terms spelled out unambiguously in the agreements attached to the complaint. Those agreements included clear contractual limitations on the future use of GM's technology, and on the transfer of that technology to others," the GM filing stressed.
Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.
Please log in here to leave a comment.