• Sweden's news in English
 
app_header_v3

Judge defends dominant-sex rape acquittal

The Local · 14 Jan 2014, 10:39

Published: 14 Jan 2014 10:39 GMT+01:00

"I knew the moment I took on this case that there would be an outcry if there was a not-guilty verdict," Lund district court judge Ralf G. Larsson wrote in an op-ed published on Tuesday on Sveriges Televison (SVT) debate website SVT Debatt. 

Larsson underlined that if the suspect had not intended to rape the woman, he could not be convicted of rape. 

"If the thought had not occurred to him, that she did not want to have sex with him, then he didn't have any intention to do what he did," the judge wrote.

"He should have been acquitted. That's how the rule of law works and that's how the rule of law should work if I'm going to be a part of the justice system."

He further elaborated that there were parts of the plaintiff's and the suspect's versions of events that testified to the man refraining from certain acts on the insistence of the woman.

"The woman had made very clear to the man at least six times that she did not want to do what he wanted to do," Larsson wrote. "For example, oral and anal sex came up, and at each such incident the man did not proceed with what he wanted to do." 

Larsson went on to argue that no judge in Sweden should feel pressured by potential media fallout in difficult cases.

"If what is happening right now in mass and social media has the potential to scare less experienced judges, we're on a dangerous path," Larsson wrote.

The ruling has caused outrage among many Swedes, with protests planned for the weekend, most likely in Stockholm, the Skånska Dagbladet newspaper reports.

The alleged rape took place in the man's apartment after the two, who did not know each other previously, met at a restaurant. While both agree that the evening included consensual kissing, the two had different views about what happened when the man initiated intercourse.

"I expressed very clearly that I didn't want to, so there was no way he could misunderstand me," the woman told investigators. She explained, however, that the man became more aggressive as her protests increased, adding that he "seemed to like it".

The woman screamed so much and so loudly that she eventually lost her voice while the man continued. At one point, he covered her nose and mouth so she couldn't breathe and slapped her in the face, Metro reported.

Story continues below…

While the woman told investigators she "expressed very clearly" that she didn't want to have sex, the man told the court that he was convinced the woman was into rough sex, saying he received "very clear signals" that she enjoyed what he was doing.

However, the court ruled it had not been proven that the 27-year-old had acted with intent to act against the woman's wishes, a ruling that left many observers seething.

"Hey! What do you think about putting together a 'Kärrtorp-massive' demo (peaceful), outside/near parliament say next week where we are in the thousands to demand better sex crimes legislation? Mutual consent Act NOW!" Swedish journalist Cissi Wallin wrote via Facebook.

According to critics, the Lund court ruling sets a dangerous precedent that allows the assailant the right to define rape.

The Local (news@thelocal.se)

Your comments about this article

Today's headlines
Eight teens suspected of child rape in Sweden
A police car investigating a separate incident in Gothenburg. Photo: Fredrik Sandberg/TT

Eight teens suspected of child rape in Sweden
4 hours ago

Eight teenage boys have been arrested in connection with an alleged gang rape of a child in Gothenburg in western Sweden.

Traffic woes as Sweden's snowy weather returns
A frozen car in Stockholm last month. Photo: Tomas Oneborg/SvD/TT

Traffic woes as Sweden's snowy weather returns
5 hours ago

Thought spring was on its way? Who did you think you were kidding? It's Sweden in February!

Julian Assange
'Sweden is a country with fair reputation for justice'
Julian Assange at Ecuador's London embassy. Photo: AP Photo/Kirsty Wigglesworth

'Sweden is a country with fair reputation for justice'
6 hours ago

British PM David Cameron has backed Swedish prosecutors, saying Wikileaks founder Julian Assange should hand himself over and "end this sorry saga".

'Dildo T-shirt' photo defended by Swedish newspaper
Does this really look like a dildo? Photo: Peter Palmquist

'Dildo T-shirt' photo defended by Swedish newspaper
7 hours ago

Can you see a dildo in this photo?

The Local Guide
Who is the shy Swede behind all those global smash hits?
Taylor Swift, Max Martin and Katy Perry. Photo: Matt Sayles/Chris Pizzello/Felipe Dana/AP/Invision

Who is the shy Swede behind all those global smash hits?
9 hours ago

You may not know his name, but you have definitely heard his music. This is Max Martin, the Swede behind your favourite pop hits.

Teenager arrested after asylum housing stabbing
Swedish police investigating a different crime. Johan Nilsson/TT

Teenager arrested after asylum housing stabbing
11 hours ago

A 17-year-old is being held after a man was left seriously injured following a stabbing in Västervik in southern Sweden.

Swedish hitmaker Max Martin takes home top music prize
Swedish producer Max Martin. Photo: Axel Öberg/Polar Music Prize

Swedish hitmaker Max Martin takes home top music prize
12 hours ago

Introducing the 2016 winners of Sweden's prestigious Polar Music Prize.

Border checks
Swedish coast guard prepares for spring refugee dockings
The Swedish coast guard in action this week. Photo: Emil Langvad/TT

Swedish coast guard prepares for spring refugee dockings
13 hours ago

Staff say it will become more difficult to patrol waters between Sweden and Denmark when locals start sailing for pleasure in the spring.

The Local List
Six tales that prove romance is far from dead in Sweden
Could your Swedish romance start like this? Photo: Ulf Lundin/Image Bank Sweden

Six tales that prove romance is far from dead in Sweden
14 hours ago

Dating can be tough in Sweden, but love stories still exist, so if you're single ahead of Valentine's Day, read this!

Julian Assange
Will Swedish prosecutors question Assange in London?
Julian Assange at Ecuador's London embassy. Photo: AP Photo/Kirsty Wigglesworth

Will Swedish prosecutors question Assange in London?
21 hours ago

UPDATED: Julian Assange's lawyer has said he "cannot answer today" if the Wikileaks founder will agree to let Swedish prosecutors interrogate him at Ecuador's embassy.

Sponsored Article
How to set up shop in the 'Silicon Valley of Sweden'
Travel
Why are people so happy in Malmö?
Sponsored Article
US taxes and FATCA: 'The time for hiding is over'
National
Less than one percent of Swedish crimes linked to refugees
Features
Single? Here are the ten Swedish words you have to learn
Blog updates

9 February

Förr, förut, förrän, före and … innan! (The Swedish Teacher) »

"Hejsan! A long time ago, I got this question: It would be a huge help if you could…" READ »

 

5 February

Editor’s blog, February 5th (The Local Sweden) »

"Hello readers, A friend of mine wrote from abroad this week to ask me if international media…" READ »

 
 
 
Sponsored Article
Swiss hospitality: The ladder to your international career
Fastighetsbyrån
Gallery
Property of the week: Lindesberg, Örebro
Sponsored Article
Ice magic at north Sweden island lodges
Lifestyle
VIDEO: What's the fuss about Sweden's semla bun?
Culture
Ten fab Swedish hits for February
Finest
Gallery
People-watching: February 6th-7th
Sponsored Article
Just landed? Here's the secret to finding work in Stockholm
Travel
Stockholm's eight REAL no-go zones
Sponsored Article
Stockholm's secret ski resort: Kungsberget
Gallery
People-watching: February 3rd
National
'How confronting the man who robbed me gave me closure'
Sponsored Article
Luleå: 8 winter must-dos in Sweden's far north
Analysis & Opinion
DEBATE: Why are Swedes so obsessed with Nordic skiing?
Culture
See which Swedish museums are now opening up for free
Gallery
Property of the week: Insjön, Nacka
National
VIDEO: Tensions caught on camera inside Swedish asylum home
Gallery
People-Watching: January 29th - 31st
International
How will Sweden deport up to 80,000 failed asylum seekers?
Sport
When you gotta go... Swedish racing dog does poo and then takes gold
Sport
Guess who just got a HUGE pay rise?
Travel
WATCH: Five top tips for safe ice skating on Sweden's gorgeous lakes
Gallery
People-watching: January 27th
National
'Sweden could be at war within years'
Gallery
Property of the week: Öjersbo, Kungsbacka
International
Why is the Pope coming to Sweden?
3,465
jobs available
PSD Media
PSD Media is marketing company that offers innovative solutions for online retailers. We provide modern solutions that help increase traffic and raise conversion. Visit our site at:
psdmedia.se