• Sweden edition
 
Hundreds of great job opportunities for foreign professionals at Sweden's top employers - in cooperation with Monster, Experteer, Stepstone, and CareerBuilder.
What
Where
730
jobs available
Find English-speaking professionals with The Local.
Advertise a vacancy
Op-Ed
'Wrong to flood firms with bad job candidates'
Routine jobmatching process at Arbetsförmdeling, argues critic Nima Sanandaji.

'Wrong to flood firms with bad job candidates'

Published: 04 Mar 2014 07:15 CET

Last week, chaos ensued when thousands of jobseekers tried to file into a central Stockholm office of the national jobs agency (Arbetsförmedlingen). The job agency had by mistake invited 61,000 people to a meeting originally intended for 1,400. A member of staff pressed the panic button to call for police help as the office was inundated. 

One would be forgiven for believing that it was all orchestrated as a media event, illustrating Sweden’s persistent problem with labour market exclusion.

In 2006, the government coalition broke a long spell of Social Democrat rule, promising to create jobs. At that time, more than one million Swedes in working age were supported by benefits rather than a pay check, due to unemployment, sick leave, or early retirement.

Workfare reforms have helped bring that number down somewhat, but it still remains at around 800,000 individuals. Arguably, Sweden can do much more to bring down unemployment. The disastrous meeting at the jobs agency illustrates one of the necessary changes: The job agency must do a much better job at matching people with suitable jobs, not just any job.

Salah Haghgo, who works at Stockholm municipality's own labour matching office (Arbetsmarknadsförvaltningen), recently told me that the national agency has major difficulties fulfilling its two main duties: To help the unemployed get jobs, and to provide the labour market with skilled workers.

“The incident last Wednesday in my view proves that,” Haghgo said, adding that the incident made him want to know more about the event intended for 1,400 jobseekers - in itself no slim figure.

"Those 1,400 – were they fully matched to the needs of the invited businesses? How many actual jobs were at stake at this meeting? Were the invited companies and businesses actually asking for 1,400 applicants? What made the agency take this broad approach?”

And is a broad approach the right approach? Definitely not.

Arbetsförmedlingen has billions of kronor at its disposal but many firms are reluctant to even advertise for new employees with the agency.

The reason is simple: If the national jobs agency finds out that you have an open position as say, a chef, their administrators will start informing unemployed individuals they're in contact with. A few might have some relevant experience, training, or education, but many if not most often have no chance of actually getting a job that they would not do well.

A professional agency, in contrast, would make a selection of the best applicants, while Arbetsförmedling not only encourages hundreds or even thousands to go after the same job, but also reprimands any jobseeker who does not apply to available jobs.

The end result is that employers can receive hundreds of phone calls and visits, mainly from people who are far from suitable for the role. Saying "Sorry, we can’t employ you" to person after person is time consuming and, for most people, anything but a positive experience. And receiving this answer hundreds of times is hardly encouraging for the jobseeker.

Last Wednesday’s mistake of inviting 61,000 people to a meeting with a few jobs on offer was a one‑time mistake. But 1,400 is also a lot of people, and illustrates the agency's routine practice.

Arbetsförmedlingen needs to take the task of matching available jobs with unemployed individuals more seriously, or alternatively we need allow private companies to compete with the agency.  

Nima Sanandaji, a Swedish writer of Kurdish origin, has written numerous books and reports about policy issues in Sweden. He is a regular contributor to The Local.

The Local (news@thelocal.se)


Don't miss...X
Left Right

Your comments about this article:

The comments below have not been moderated in advance and are not produced by The Local unless clearly stated. Readers are responsible for the content of their own comments. Comments that breach our terms and conditions will be removed.

Your Swedish Career
When Matthew Volsky first came to Sweden he didn't think he would stick around. Six years and a pioneering invention later he tells The Local about the medical device which is helping save lives around the world.
Jenna Iwanchuk had never visited Europe, let alone Sweden, before she moved from Canada to Gothenburg two years ago, she tells The Local. Now she runs a local pet shop ably assisted by her dog, Tindra.
US expat Faith George tells The Local about how she mastered the Swedish language, seeing the positives in being made redundant, and how she plans to show Swedes another side of the United States.
What does an eccentric Swedish farmer have in common with an Australian paleontologist? No, it's not a Ross from Friends joke, it's about a petrified fern and a career in scientific research in Sweden.
After six years studying medicine in Russia, Mumbai-born doctor Sandeep Jha chose Sweden over India for his career. He tells The Local about the chance encounter that lead him to the hidden beauty of cardiology.
US micro brewer Kevin Zelnio talks about the importance of Swedish contacts, how Swedes are Europe's most progressive beer makers, and how brewing beer in the Swedish forest makes him feel like Walter White from Breaking Bad.
Swedish Employment News
Sweden last year attracted more talent than it lost, with engineers topping the table of immigrants. In Europe, the biggest influx of professionals was to Germany, but a Middle Eastern country outperformed all surveyed markets.
"We have to hit the brakes and the gas at the same time." Does your Swedish boss confuse you? You're not alone. Swedes have crowned that phrase as the worst workplace cliché of the year.
What does an eccentric Swedish farmer have in common with an Australian paleontologist? No, it's not a Ross from Friends joke, it's about a petrified fern and a career in scientific research in Sweden.
Municipal staff in Gothenburg will act as guinea pigs in a proposed push for six-hour workdays with full pay, with hopes that it will cut down on sick leave, boost efficiency, and ultimately save Sweden money.
Are you looking for a job in Sweden but having trouble with your CV? Here are the Swedish words you should avoid, courtesy of LinkedIn's annual list of "overrated" buzzwords.
A new survey looking at how Swedes feel about their job has put one profession far down on the bottom rung of well-being in the workplace.

International Sales - Stockholm based
Marcus Evans is looking for International Sales Executives
FULL JOB AD »

THG is hiring for the Stockholm office!
THG is looking for International Sports Sales Executives to sell their VIP hospitality facilities at major sports events.
FULL JOB AD »

Fortum
Stockholm
Stepstone
Added 07/28/14

Expedia Europe
Stockholm
Stepstone
Added 07/28/14

Michael Page
Gothenburg
Stepstone
Added 07/28/14

Michael Page
Göteborg
Stepstone
Added 07/28/14

Tele2 Sverige AB
Stockholm
Stepstone
Added 07/28/14

Volvo
Göteborg
Careerbuilder
Added 07/28/14

Volvo
Göteborg
Careerbuilder
Added 07/28/14

Michael Page
Göteborg
Careerbuilder
Added 07/28/14

Volvo
Göteborg
Careerbuilder
Added 07/28/14

Randstad
Kista
Careerbuilder
Added 07/28/14