Swedish historian touts Nordic power bloc

Published: 27 Oct 09 08:54 CET
Online: http://www.thelocal.se/22898/20091027/

Dictionary tool Double click on a word to get a translation

Sweden should consider joining its Nordic neighbours in forming a five-country federation in order to increase the region’s weight on the international stage, a Swedish historian proposes.

A union between the five Nordic countries – Sweden, Norway, Denmark, Finland, and Iceland – would give them a seat at big international gatherings, writes social scientist, historian, and author Gunnar Wetterberg in an opinion article in the Dagens Nyheter (DN) newspaper.

In proposing the creation of a Nordic 'bloc of ice', Wetterberg suggests that Denmark’s Queen Margrethe II would be the union’s obvious leader, drawing parallels between the Kalmar Union, which united Sweden, Denmark, and Norway from 1397 to 1523 and was governed by the Danish Queen Margareta.

Wetterberg describes several areas which would give a Nordic federal state significant international influence.

Together, the five countries would be the world’s tenth largest economy – larger than Russia’s and Brazil’s, and one of the five or six largest economies in the European Union.

“By harmonizing economic legislation, the EU/EEA makes a Nordic union easier, but hardly reduces the need for one,” writes Wetterberg, referring to legislation related to the European Union and the European Economic Area.

With greater influence, the Nordic region could better protect its interests within the EU and find that key positions on the European Commission were more easily within reach, he believes.

However, Wetterberg admits that a unitary Nordic state isn’t realistic “and perhaps not desirable either – each country’s distinctive character has value in and of itself”.

One reason why he suggest Queen Margrethe II lead his proposed Nordic union is the symbolic value of the name.

“If it’s too hard for the others to swallow, the post could rotate between the countries,” writes Wetterberg.

The advantages of unification are so great today that politicians ought to take the idea of a Kalmar Union seriously, he believes.

“With 25 million residents, Nordic culture would have a stronger base than it does now. The market for Nordic literature, theatre, and music should be much larger than today,” Wetterberg writes.

He admits, however, that language might be a problem.

“One solution would be to have all students learn another Nordic language from the start, in addition to their mother tongue,” he proposes.

He believes that a unified Nordic region is completely realistic, “not least because of Swedish arrogance has subsided in recent decades”.

TT/The Local (news@thelocal.se/08 656 6518)

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Fark It! Digg This Facebook  Share everywhere
Send to a friend Printable version Twitter This

Your comments about this article:

The comments below have not been moderated in advance and are not produced by The Local unless clearly stated. Readers are responsible for the content of their own comments. Comments that breach our terms and conditions will be removed.

10:58 October 27, 2009 by Dr. Dillner
It is worth a try, but maybe not achievable until 2060, and which "other" Nordic language did he have in mind?
11:15 October 27, 2009 by Kaethar
It would have to be Finnish or Icelandic. Icelandic would be out of the question though but Finnish remains an option (or another Scandinavian dialect for the less linguistically gifted). Finns already learn Swedish in school and Icelanders already learn Danish in schools.
11:17 October 27, 2009 by Hauhr
"However, Wetterberg admits that a unitary Nordic state isn't realistic"

"He believes that a unified Nordic region is completely realistic"

Is it realistic or not?
11:51 October 27, 2009 by misssh
sound like a good idea if you ask me!!
11:59 October 27, 2009 by Balticcrosser
'11:17 October 27, 2009 by Hauhr

"However, Wetterberg admits that a unitary Nordic state isn't realistic"

"He believes that a unified Nordic region is completely realistic"

Is it realistic or not?'

He's apparently saying that a unitary state is not realistic, but a loosely bound federal state would be. So you wouldn't turn the region into a unitary state like France, but into a federation or confederation, perhaps like Switzerland.
12:03 October 27, 2009 by sebseb
Coming from Canada, I know it is a damn bad Idea to create a federation. But maybe a confederation would be a good idea.
12:20 October 27, 2009 by zircon
Why confuse things more?
12:22 October 27, 2009 by Zoolander428
A yes, another layer of government... fantastic idea!
12:48 October 27, 2009 by Texrusso
Well, the Finns will definitely not agree, they still mentally haven't got over the over 500 years of Swedish rule and over 100 years of Russian rule. A mentally which drives the highly xenophobic state of mind in the country that yields the institutionalized racism you see in that country. The Finns are after 700 years are still yet to really understand who they are and always suspicious and cautious of Swedish domination which is also easily seen in ice-hockey, football, Euro-vision or any other international competition/contest against Sweden. The Swedish language have now been phased out as a compulsory language at school in Finland. Even the die hard Racist FINNISH Party called the True FINNS are today pushing forward as part of their racist agenda the erradication of Swedish language completely as the Finland's official second language. I still wonder what will be the fate of the 6% Swedes living in that country as most of them are either frustrated and are relocated back to Sweden slowly. The history of World leaves Finland as the only country in the history of the World that was colonized for more than 500 years. The Roman Empire, the great huns Empire, The Japanese Empire, the Otoman Empire as the list goes, all crumbled within a 100 years as the people revolt and reform. The self will of the Finnish people which they always try to portray with an unconventional guerilla winter war against Russia does not hold. The Finns will be the last to agree or support any such union with too much grip on paranoia and xenophobia.
13:07 October 27, 2009 by ppk
Go for it !

I'm 101% in favor.

But don't forget the Faroe anf Greenland!
13:37 October 27, 2009 by "green Swede"
EH,roman empire lasted a thousand years and ireland was occupied by the english for eight hundred years....must be a troll.
14:45 October 27, 2009 by eltechno
C'mon Texrusso. What's with the Finn bashing?

Considering that Finland didn't have enough to eat as recently as the 1950s, had to make actual war reparations to maintain their independence post WW II, and speak a language unlike almost any tongue on earth, I think Finland has done a superb job of post-colonial economic and social development. I just read another of those country comparisons and Finland ranks as the most successful society on earth. You may argue the methodology of these things but they aren't totally ridiculous.

http://www.businessinsider.com/america-is-the-worlds-ninth-best-country-2009-10

So the Finns are a bit touchy about Swedish colonialism. Does it really keep them from cooperating and trading with their neighbors? Didn't think so.
14:46 October 27, 2009 by Greg in Canada
This is long over due. Scandinavia is part of Europe but is unique to itself. The question is can it be made to work successfully.
14:51 October 27, 2009 by Texrusso
@Green Swede: Ireland became part of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland in 1801. The Free State left the Commonwealth to become a republic in 1949.
15:21 October 27, 2009 by jin.malmo
Since sweden is bigger than the rest of nordic countries, swedish will have a big influence.....
15:29 October 27, 2009 by FIN_E
@ Textrussian, the swedish speaking minority are Finns not Swedes. And what is your problem anyways?
15:54 October 27, 2009 by Texrusso
@eltechno: I am not talk about economic development and prosperity, after all Norway has refused to join the EU nor the Euro and So did Sweden refuse to joun the EURO. They all have their reasons. I am just trying to analyse the mindset that of the Finnish Insititution that will not support such move and that is my take. @FIN_E: They are Swedish Speaking Finns and history have it that their ancestors who once colonized Finland are Swedish. These 6% Swedish Speaking FINN although holds Finnish Passport are of Swedish decendants. They are now been marginalized in Finland and most of them are finding safety and comfort by relocating to Sweden. Have a good day ya all.
15:59 October 27, 2009 by jag2009
I would say that if this did happen Sweden would be taking control. Yet then again you never know.
16:28 October 27, 2009 by sarp
it would be high end of unified countries . . .
16:29 October 27, 2009 by lapua338
I doubt Sweden will be taking control of anything. I've lost all respect for Sweden. This nation has no backbone! Swedish justice is a joke, the welfare state is unsustainable, the armed forces couldn't fight themselves out of a wet paper bag and your liberal and politically correct attitudes will eventually destroy you as a nation. It won't be long before you will all be embracing Islamic Sharia law!

We all know that Finland was historically part of Sweden and from 1809 an autonomous Grand Duchy within the Russian Empire, which led to independence and civil war. At least they had the fortitude and courage to resist the Russians during the Winter War and Continuation War.

Has Sweden actually accomplished anything during the past 100 years?
16:31 October 27, 2009 by FIN_E
@Textrussian, it seems to me like your brain is being colonized by some twisted neo-nazi propaganda.
16:44 October 27, 2009 by efm
No a big state together , but just a loose organization of friends with common interest will work. It will be similar to ASEAN countries which comprise of south east asian countries of different culture but some common grounds.

It include Japan, Thailand, the Philippines, Malaysia, Indonesia and others.
17:10 October 27, 2009 by "green Swede"
texrusso,I could write paragraphs on the irrelevancies of the act of union in 1801 and the long history of english occupation of Ireland(in fact I did,but the bloody thing failed to post)but at the end of the day I fail to see what the union or the advent of the Irish republic has to do with the lenght of said occupation or the duration of the roman empire for that matter.I also have a great deal of respect and admiration for the finnish people as a whole.gs
17:19 October 27, 2009 by J.Ravier
Well, the idea sounds good, but in the facts, this project does not really change anything. If you're applying for a personal number in Sweden, you have better chances if you're from a Nordic country because of the several agreements signed between scandinavian states... The problem with the idea of such a confederation is that it sounds like the pan-scandinavian speeches from the late 19th century. Isn't it slightly nationalistic ?

Do anyone remember how the Kalmar Union ended ? I know this was 500 years ago, but it did not lead to a great development of the nations because of the interest struggles...anyways...I doubt this will happen someday.
17:34 October 27, 2009 by vladd777
Speaking-wise, objectively thinking, English is still the best option, to my mind, as most speak and understand 'our own brand' of the language.

Otherwise Norwegian seems to be the easiest to learn and understand.

Anyway I think this is a great idea and wish it would come about.
17:59 October 27, 2009 by Gwrhyr
I used to think that the Nordic countries should have stayed out of the EU while strengthening and developing the Nordic Union in a similar way as the EU - havivng a shared Nordic Crown as currency and an ever-increasing amount of integration and cooperation.

But now I live in Sweden and can see the differences between the countries up close, I think it would be a horrible idea. The idea wouldn't be swallowed for several reasons. One of them would be that Sweden would insist on Denmark implementing a restrictive alcohol policy which the Danes don't want. The fact is that right now Denmark is in a better position to teach Sweden and the rest of the Nordic countries that you don't have to live in an extremely restrictive "drug-free" society. This union would make it 100 times more difficult for Denmark to fully legalize cannabis, just as the Netherlands would prefer to fully legalize and regulate cannabis but cannot due to EU law and UN treaties which try to tell the Dutch that the question of whether adults should be allowed to consume cannabis recreationally or not isn't for individual countries to decide, but for all EU countries to decide. All that does is prevent a diversity of governmental models from taking shape so that different countries can view different ways of handling different things.
19:45 October 27, 2009 by coswede
even the flags are f_ggy
23:25 October 27, 2009 by Texrusso
@green Swede: Please leave the great Irish people out of this. Irish people are one of the most wonderful human beings I have ever met. The Irish people are humans of the hieghest level. The true people of humanity!! @FIN_E: Finland supported the Neo Nazi Germany and gave them access to Soviet Union via Finnish Lapland. There is nothing like Neo-Nazi propoganda, its all real, Finnish President then Manerheim welcomed Hitler to Helsinki and gave him a grand ducthy receiption. Finland colaborated with the Nazis. Thanks to most Swedes like Raoul Wallenberg, most Jewish lives were saved during the second World war. Sweden is still the greatest country in Europe no matter what you RACIST FINNS want the World to belive. Swedish diplomacy for over a 100 years saved the lives of many humans. Sweden is still the most humanitarian country in the World after the United States. Sweden remains the best form of democracy in the World. In the country of blind men, the one eye man is the King, perharps you @FIN_E is the one eye man in FInland, perhaps you are one of those one eye Finns trying to protect the darkness of your nation. The truth shall set you free. Finland is still the most RACIST country in Europe!!! Don't really care whatever excuse you give here. Have a great week! I am done with you!!!!
23:28 October 27, 2009 by DaTraveler
I came up with an idea similar to this over a year ago. Would definitely work and could be initalized within the next 10-20 years. We already know Scandys are all pretty close with 1 another.

But how would this union effect the culture/mentality of the citizens and what does this mean for defense? Would Norway/Denmark/Iceland leave NATO? That's impossible but perhaps Finland/Sweden join.
08:51 October 28, 2009 by Marc the Texan
All the Nordic countries are all pretty nationalistic. I don't see this happening. Each treasure their own cultural furniture and I don't see that changing either. I think this is only positive for some kind of Nordic ego and the point would be to in some way push Nordic culture and politics as some kind of unified conglomeration. It seems to me doing this would destroy what each of these countries seems to value the most, their national identity. The only other reason be to further increase the already fairly free trade, but you don't need a Nordic Union for that. Although, having said all that, there is probably room for more integrated military, polce and various other state services and agencies.
10:45 October 28, 2009 by KamiZ
i just read this article and then noticed people had commnted on it. so i thought 'ok people will say either yes or no'. what i was not prepared for was the neo-Nazis arriving and starting the usual hate propaganda.

personally, i think all the nordic countries have so much potential and they are all such good places to live (that's not just me, check out the Human Development Index) that a federation can be nothing but good. and such a thing will have enormous cultural, economic, defence and welfare benefits for all. another good step can be strengthening the nodric council and giving it EU like powers (not in all areas but some). that way the countries can remain independent and be united at once. it'll be sort of like a bloc within the EU.
11:28 October 28, 2009 by Zaneiro
Textrusso: And the Swedish king personally shaked hands with Mannerheim after the war, for not letting germans to occupy Sweden. Germans were after minerals of sweden, but Mannerheim wouldn't agree that as a part of the deal. So know your history, man!
15:38 October 28, 2009 by Labhrais
Yet another Swede that has not understood the content, intent or obligations of the ratification of the EU constitution by Sweden..
20:12 October 28, 2009 by svenskdod
Awesome idea!!! They could have a Vikingarlament.

Seriously though, the constitutions of all countries would have to change significantly, and there would be overwhelming rejection from the mundanes. In every sense it would help all of the countries. Denmark's wind farms, Norway's fisheries, Hydro dam's and oil fields, Island's geographic location (Militarily), Sweden's Pytt i Panna and Finland's cheap booze.

There is nothing to loose except their identity, and really were all human aren't we?
02:38 October 30, 2009 by Luke35711
Scandinavia only exists if one is looking from afar. If you live here, you realise that there is a lot of nationalism around here. I suspect controlling Swedes are the only ones keen some sort in integration: bigger government, more power, more politics, more meetings, less honest work, how lovely!
20:33 October 30, 2009 by Ron Pavellas
As an immigrant (and undoubtedly somewhat ignorant) Swede from the USA (dual citizen) I think it a positive idea for the political reasons expounded here--fie on Brussels. I haven't known any Icelandic folks, but I've known people from the other Nordic countries and descendants of people from the other Nordic countries. Their values seem quite alike, especially in comparison to other European countries, and I feel quite comfortable with them--I'm even getting to get to like Lagom (not so sure about jantelagen, however). It is amusing to see the minor differences between say, Norwegians and Swedes, so exaggerated when, from the outside, the two sets of folks seem quite alike in most respects. My daughter's mother-in-law is descended directly form Finnish immigrants to the USA and retains ties with the old country. She is a marvelous and admirable woman. MY dad had much to do with immigrant Finns in San Francisco setting up a consumer's cooperative during WWII. He admired them all, and especially the Finnish people for withstanding the Soviets. Danes seem quite friendly and open and I've liked all I've met. And, I married a Swede. Let's all get together over some snaps and do a deal!
20:21 November 3, 2009 by israeli
what a relief. i was sure the next move of the swedish hunta would be to declare a federation with iran and syria. well now the swedish entity will be diluted into a wider aryan blond arena. i trust the danish nation to stop the islmization tendencies of the IKEA state.
15:10 November 26, 2009 by Gwrhyr
I really am a firm believer that the Nordic countries should have unified in a similar way as the EU has. The Nordic Council should have expanded its role and a unified currency - the Nordic Crown, should have been made. Add a customs union and have the Nordic countries stay out of the EU and Euro and the Nordic region of the world would be a powerful global player, both economically and strategically. Carl Bildt would never have been marginalized like he was in Sri Lanka were the Nordic countries unified with each other and not with Southern Europe. France, Germany, and the UK will always be the big players in the EU, will always call the shots, and will treat the Nordic countries as small little brother's to boss around. That won't change. Yet all Nordic people know that their region has more to offer the world than that. It is idiocy that there never was a unified Nordic currency.
ADD YOUR COMMENT   (YOU MUST LOG IN OR REGISTER TO MAKE A COMMENT)
Today's headlines
50,000 Swedish households without water

50,000 Swedish households without water

More than 50,000 households in the Karlstad region in western Sweden were without water on Saturday due a serious water leak. Although service has been restored, residents are advised to boil drinking water for the next several days. READ (2 COMMENTS) »

Roddick trumps Söderling in semi-finals

American tennis star Andy Roddick beat sixth-seeded Swede Robin Söderling on Saturday in a 6-4, 3-6, 6-3 victory at the Indian Wells Masters 1000 on Saturday. Roddick will now face Ivan Ljubicic in Sunday's tennis final. READ (1 COMMENT) »

Swedish woman faces charges for falsely accusing father of rape

A young Swedish woman who falsely accused her father of rape will now face charges of her own. The father had received a five-year prison sentence in 2007 after the then 17-year-old girl reported he had sexually assaulted her. READ (7 COMMENTS) »

16-year-old arrested for attempted murder

A 19-year-old male sustained serious injuries during a knife fight on Saturday night in the neighborhood of Varberga in Örebro in central Sweden. Another 16-year-old boy was later arrested for the assault. READ »

Risk of Easter strike looms

Negotiations between the Commercial Employees´ Union (Handelsanställdas förbund) and the Swedish Federation of Trade (Svensk Handel) employers' organisation have stalled, according to the trade union. READ »

Human trafficking pair imprisoned on appeal

In the first case of its kind in Sweden, a Stockholm court has found two men guilty of human trafficking after they lured two teenage boys from their home in Romania to a life of crime. READ (8 COMMENTS) »

Annika Östberg moved to rehabilitation centre

Sweden’s convicted double murderer Annika Östberg Deasy, who is due to be released in May 2011, has been moved from a female prison to a rehabilitation centre where she will work at a day nursery for dogs. READ »

Reinfeldt leads voter support poll

Reinfeldt leads voter support poll

Swedish Prime Minister Fredrik Reinfeldt retains his position at the top of the party leader board in a new survey on voter confidence while support for opposition leader Mona Sahlin continues to decline. READ (8 COMMENTS) »

More Politics
Find a new job in Sweden now
21/03 R&D Group Manager Electronics Design ESAB AB
ESAB AB
Göteborg
21/03 R&D Group Manager Mechanical Design ESAB AB
ESAB AB
Göteborg
21/03 R&D Group Manager Test & Verification ESAB AB
ESAB AB
Göteborg
20/03 Software Developer
Outpost 24 AB
Karlskrona
20/03 Regional Manager (m/f) Scandinavia
EOS GmbH Electro Optical Systems
Scandinavia
20/03 Java Developer
Outpost 24 AB
Karlskrona

ALL JOBS »



Blog Update: 110% LAGOM

21 March 11:10

Result! »

"If you read Swedish, the CCCC review is as good as it gets, if not the picture of the crowd speaks a thousand words..." READ »

Highlights
RESTAURANTS »
Find a table at Sweden's best restaurants - then review them on The Local in our new restaurant section
Photo: www.stureplan.se
GALLERY »
Out on the town: March 12-13
Photo: www.erikolsson.se
GALLERY »
Property of the Week
Photo: Chesty Morgan
LIFESTYLE »
What's On in Sweden: March 19th - 25th: Chesty Morgan in Stockholm, Cameroonian Jazz in Gothenburg, a spin on Cinderella in Malmö, English comedy in Linköping.
March in Sweden: Slush, bears and skiing royals
LIFESTYLE »
March in Sweden: Slush, bears and skiing royals
Photo: www.finest.se
GALLERY »
The weekend's 'finest': March 12-13
Photo: Anastasia Pirvu
GALLERY »
Stockholm/Uppsala Street Style, March 7-8
Photo: Piteå Kommun
SPONSORED ARTICLE
Swedish Rail Destinations with SJ: Piteå is best known as a summer destination, but wintertime offers skating across the ice in the Gulf of Botnia and cosy dinners in the pretty town centre.
Latest news from The Local in Germany
Blog
  • 5 questions for Maria Ernestam
    The novels of journalist-become-author Maria Ernestam are both serious and humorous. Sometimes compared with works by Isabel Allende, Fay Weldon, Ingrid Noll and Ruth Rendell, Ernestam's books have...
  • Film studio Sweden
    Sweden — with its midnight sun, northern lights and areas with certainty of snow — is attracting filmmakers from all around the world. Besides an exotic environment, Sweden has other advantages as a...
  • Veronica Hedenmark
    “I’d like to travel and fly without having to think about the practical arrangements — but the practical part severely restricts my movements,” says entrepreneur Veronica Hedenmark, who uses an...
  • Victoria Webster
    Victoria Webster became Sweden’s first specialist in emergency medical care. This attracted considerable media attention, since she has a cerebral palsy (CP)* disorder.
Essentials

Jobs - in Sweden, in English
Get your career on track with our job listings from Sweden's top employers.

Property - renting or buying in Sweden
Navigating the minefield of renting or buying an apartment or house in Sweden.

Weather
"There is no bad weather, just bad clothes," say the Swedes. Here's the forecast for everyone else.

Introducing...
Every week The Local serves up a spicy helping of Swedish celebrity for your delectation.

Stockholm Syndrome
Tales of crazy Swedish classes, hamfisted attempts to understand - and explain - real Swedes, and varied experiences of fellow foreigners gathered for your amusement.

Search News


Register

Register now for:
> Free use of noticeboard
> Special discounts
> Weekly news roundup
> Unlimited use of discuss

REGISTER FOR FREE »

Jobs in Sweden, in English

433 jobs in Sweden, in English
130 new jobs this week
3 new jobs today

ALL JOBS »

Doctor of Psychology
Therapy in English

David Schultz PsyD
Individuals & couples
In Stockholm in person or by phone or video conferencing
www.anxiousorblue.se
Play football in Stockholm
Kick-off the new football season with LFC, Stockholm's premier English-speaking football club.
MORE INFO
JOB: Digital Ad Operations Coordinator - Stockholm
The Local seeks a digital advertising specialist to administer advertising operations for our network of sites
FULL JOB DETAILS
Lovely Weekly Apartment Rental-Stockholm
Charming apartment in Lidingö that overlooks the forest, sea and city! 60 sq m, 2 rooms, sleeps 2-4 people. 7969 sek/week.
MORE INFO
Counseling in English Individuals & Couples - Stockholm
Beth Rogerson PhD - Clinical, Marriage & Family Therapist
Click or call 08-5580 1266 now
JOB: Sales manager - Stockholm
The Local is seeking a talented media sales professional to drive our online advertising sales
FULL JOB DETAILS
Visiting Stockholm?
Then you'll find The Local's new Stockholm Section useful. Find pics, guides, news and lots of useful information about Stockholm.
www.thelocal.se/stockholm
The Local's new Marketplace
Find products and services that are specifically focused on English speakers living in Sweden!
FULL DETAILS
Welcome to Adlon Hotel in Stockholm
A perfect location both for business and pleasure. Centrally located, with atmosphere.
www.adlon.se
Winter archipelago tours
Visit Stockholm's beautiful archipelago. Great boat tours for all preferences.
MORE INFORMATION