Sign up for the editor's
weekly newsletter
- Sweden edition
- Change edition:
- France |
- Germany |
- Norway |
- Switzerland
Reader Offer
February 14, 2012
Doctor charged over baby's death
Published: 1 Feb 10 14:15 CET | Double click on a word to get a translation
Online: http://www.thelocal.se/24724/20100201/
The paediatrician suspected of the alleged mercy killing of a baby at Astrid Lindgren's Children's Hospital in Stockholm in September 2008 has been charged with manslaughter.
- Children's hospital faces probe over baby death (22 Jan 10)
- Baby 'could have died' due to hospital drug error (12 Oct 09)
- Doctor vindicated in newborn's death (6 Oct 09)
The prosecutor, Peter Claeson, explained in a press release on Monday that he expects to secure a conviction in court and that the prosecution's case is based on forensic reports and witness testimony from those present at the time of the baby's death on September 20th 2008.
"The evidence is strong," Claeson said to news agency TT, arguing that the doctor and no one else is responsible for the baby's death.
The three-month-old baby was terminally ill with serious brain damage after having been born 15 weeks premature. The birth was complicated and the baby was born unconscious due to a lack of oxygen.
The baby girl's condition worsened when a nurse administered an overdose of saline solution at birth.
A subsequent ultrasound revealed that the newborn had suffered from cerebral haemorrhaging on both sides of her brain.
The case has generated a heated debate in Sweden.
Medical colleagues and the unions have roundly criticized the police and prosecutors for their handling of the case following the public arrest of the doctor at her place of work in March 2009.
The doctor was subsequently released from custody after a successful appeal from her lawyer, Björn Hurtig, and denies any wrongdoing. She has been suspended from her position at the hospital throughout the course of the investigation.
A report from Sweden’s National Board of Health and Welfare (Socialstyrelsen) published in October 2009 cleared the doctor of any wrongdoing in connection with the baby's death.
"We've reviewed all available documentation and spoken with healthcare workers and the information we’ve collected is in order. We can’t see that there were any shortcomings in the care and handling of the little girl," Staffan Blom, head regional supervisor at the board, said at the time.
The board did however confirm the findings from an autopsy conducted on the baby which found abnormally high levels of both Pentothal and morphine in the child's blood.
Staffan Blom confirmed that the board could not explain the existence of the anaesthetic as its use was not mentioned anywhere in the medical records.
Manslaughter carries a penalty of between six and ten years in prison in Sweden.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
Fark It!
Digg This
Share everywhere
Send to a friend
Printable version
Twitter ThisToday's headlines
Swedish blogger snaps commuting 'macho men'
A Stockholm woman fed up with male passengers on public transport taking up the space of women sitting next to them, has started a blog snapping secret pics of straddle-legged commuters and posting them on the internet. READ (34 COMMENTS) »
Swedish town gives 'Negro Village' new name
A suburb of Mjällby, southern Sweden, known by locals as ‘Negro Village’ for forty years, will be changing its name after a storm of recent attention. READ (12 COMMENTS) »
German 'tourist' living in Gothenburg airport
A 27-year-old German man has been living at the Gothenburg Landvetter airport for two months having no wish to return to Germany and nowhere to go in Sweden. READ (12 COMMENTS) »
Dramatic rise in dementia numbers in Sweden
Every second Swede is at risk of developing dementia, according to a new study from Umeå University, which concentrated on the 85+ population in northern Sweden. READ (2 COMMENTS) »
Masked man raped cyclist in Malmö park
After a 28-year-old woman was pulled off her bicycle and raped by an unidentified assailant in Malmö over the weekend, and police are fearing it could be the work of a budding serial rapist. READ (16 COMMENTS) »
Narcolepsy victims in new compensation bid
Families of children in Sweden suffering from narcolepsy caused by vaccination for the swine flu can expect some form of compensation, Swedish health minister Göran Hägglund said on Sunday in response to new calls for help from parents. READ (1 COMMENT) »
Löfven ready to negotiate over nuclear power
The new leader of the Social Democrats Stefan Löfven has indicated he's ready to negotiate with the government over the future of nuclear power despite a previous party decision to phase out nuclear energy in Sweden. READ (3 COMMENTS) »
One in five Swedes 'believes in ghosts'
One in five Swedes believes that people rise from the grave after they've died, a new survey has shown. READ (15 COMMENTS) »
More National
- 14/02 Prison deemed 'unacceptable' after late loo roll »
- 13/02 Masked man raped cyclist in Malmö park (16 comments) »
- 12/02 Malmö murders linked to fake online firms: report (9 comments) »
- 12/02 Teacher held after having sex with teen students (4 comments) »
- 12/02 Man arrested after 'hugging thief' attack (1 comment) »
- 11/02 Psychiatrist had sex with patient during therapy (16 comments) »
- 11/02 73 cats found in three-room apartment (5 comments) »
- 10/02 Court delays Swedish bride murder trial (3 comments) »
- 10/02 Four arrested for Malmö gang slaying (41 comments) »
- 10/02 Agency to probe doc who broke baby’s neck (18 comments) »
20 things to know before moving to Sweden
As diverse as Sweden is, there are a few societal norms that are distinctly Swedish. Understanding a handful of them will hopefully prepare you culturally before you relocate. When you're invited home to a Swede, you better be on time and take your shoes off, writes expat Lola Akinmade-Åkerström. Read more »
How far can English take you in Sweden?
Sweden is a country where almost everyone can speak English. So why bother to learn Swedish? Edina Varnagy from Hungary managed with English for a whole year but then found that Swedish could open doors – to a job, a social life and greater understanding. Read more »
Blog Update: Julie's Nordic Island
"The ice dripped in the winter sun. It was the first day when the light had been intense enough to cause dripping in the sunlight. To hear it was an extraordinary wakeup call. The cycle was happening again as it always does, always will (or so we think). I imagined that on my summer island, the bees..." READ »
- 11/2 09:27 Fika Quiz (The Swedish Teacher)
- 10/2 10:47 Reefer Madness (110% LAGOM)
- 07/2 12:55 Queen of Diamonds (The Diplomatic Dispatch)
Highlights
|
|
Swedish word of the day
fin
adjective
Fin means anyhting from sweet to proper. When someone says, Du är så fin it's quite a compliment.
Latest news from The Local in Germany
- 13/02 Dog attack victim tries to save owner's life »
- 13/02 Olympic bosses cannot ban underwear luger »
More news from Germany at thelocal.de
Latest news from The Local in Switzerland
More news from Switzerland at thelocal.ch
Latest news from The Local in France
More news from France at thelocal.fr
Latest news from The Local in Norway
- 13/02 Norway beer makers can't show beer »
- 13/02 Norwegian billionaire to buy 10 oil tankers: report »
More news from Norway at thelocal.no
Blog
New book about Sweden – get to know the country
Sweden – Up North, Down to Earth is a book about Sweden today. A country of natural beauty and open space, and a society focused on equality, human rights and sustainability. Meet regular and astonishing Swedes, supercars and indie rock bands, vampires and royalties.
Buy your copy of Sweden – Up North, Down to Earth from Sweden Bookshop
In cooperation with DoToday
Register
Register now for:
> Free use of noticeboard
> Special discounts
> Weekly news roundup
> Unlimited use of discuss
Jobs in Sweden, in English
512 jobs available
231 new jobs this week
16 new jobs today
- Baseband testers to telecom job in Mid Sweden
- System developer within Q&A (Java och C) in Mid Sweden
- Baseband testers to telecom job in Mid Sweden
- Production leader
- Software Engineer - Anti Cheat
- Test Environment Engineers - WCDMA and LTE
- Test Environment Engineer - WRBS and Aeroflex
- Test Environment Engineers - BTS and Tools
- Operations Live Maintenance Engineer
- Passionate about Operations? Welcome to Klarna!
Noticeboard
Discuss
- 07:29 Baseball in Gothenburg?
- 07:24 Irish Girl has just moved to Sweden!
- 05:35 Skattereduktion after buying an apartment
- 00:31 What does that mean?
- 23:26 Pop tarts in Stockholm
- 23:19 Had problems with my boyfriend
- 23:09 Working with no knowledge of Swedish?
- 22:46 Tax deductible for rented property
- 21:04 Which song are you currently listening to?
- 20:45 Should I ask her on a date or not?
English Speaking Therapist Stockholm
British-Australian Male Counsellor. Counselling Therapy for Depression, Mental Health, Sex, Relationship & Expat Issues
08-559 22 636 or CLICK HERE
British-Australian Male Counsellor. Counselling Therapy for Depression, Mental Health, Sex, Relationship & Expat Issues
08-559 22 636 or CLICK HERE
Counseling in English
Individuals & Couples - Stockholm Beth Rogerson PhD - Clinical, Marriage & Family Therapist
Click or call 08-5580 1266 now
Individuals & Couples - Stockholm Beth Rogerson PhD - Clinical, Marriage & Family Therapist
Click or call 08-5580 1266 now
Doctor of Psychology
Therapy in English in Stockholm Trained in California Individuals & Couples (08) 93 81 48 FREE phone consultation
Visit anxiousorblue.se
Therapy in English in Stockholm Trained in California Individuals & Couples (08) 93 81 48 FREE phone consultation
Visit anxiousorblue.se
Get on the Tennis Court with www.babolatshop.se
The new Online Tennis Store with the largest selection of Babolat Products in Sweden
http://www.babolatshop.se
The new Online Tennis Store with the largest selection of Babolat Products in Sweden
http://www.babolatshop.se
Turning Point Counseling
Turning Point Counselling centre offers the international community of Stockholm a safe space for personal development, counselling and coaching.
http://www.turning-point.se/show.asp
Turning Point Counselling centre offers the international community of Stockholm a safe space for personal development, counselling and coaching.
http://www.turning-point.se/show.asp
Swedish Down Town
Swedish Down Town PR Consulting and Productions is an innovative business company which provides valuable assistance with Public Relations and Communications in the swedish and the international market.
www.swedishdowntown.com
Swedish Down Town PR Consulting and Productions is an innovative business company which provides valuable assistance with Public Relations and Communications in the swedish and the international market.
www.swedishdowntown.com
The Local's new Marketplace
Find products and services that are specifically focused on English speakers living in Sweden!
FULL DETAILS
Find products and services that are specifically focused on English speakers living in Sweden!
FULL DETAILS
Your comments about this article:
The comments below have not been moderated in advance and are not produced by The Local unless clearly stated. Readers are responsible for the content of their own comments. Comments that breach our terms and conditions will be removed.
our society kill thousands of fetuses every year ... healthy fetuses ... why? becos the girl or women decided that the fetuses will be messing up their life plan ....
Then another group of parents go to other countries to adopt babies becos their economic situation if bad.
Here is a 'damaged' baby whose future life quality is one of long suffering and pain,, a quality of life that is worse than the thousands of fetuses who were killed... a quality of life we wouldn't wish upon our worse enemy.
A doctor show real courage and empathy and do what is right for the poor baby ..... something more courage and morally right than those doctors who conducted abortions .. and this pediatrician should be admired for her or his courage...
instead we are charging him or her for man slaughter?
Look around us and you can see the real manslaughter and murders in war zones around the world .. and we helped by exporting weapons, etc.
Our sense of the value of life is .... politically correct but morally bankrupt.
ha ha ... human beings ....
Moreover, 6 to 10 years in Sweden for a mercy killing but 3 years in a psychiatric hospital for premeditated murder by 16 year olds in a love triangle. Talk about arse backwards.
Also the arrest was poorly handled by a politician trying to further their career. Probably the only reason the case is continuing is that the prosecutor thinks they can't back down now. The police interrupted and delayed treatment in the hospital for current patients. There was no reason to do it in her workplace during her shift, they could've arrested her at any time since no one was in immediate danger.
The painkillers were given in conjuction with the baby being removed from life support to die.
What I also find interesting is that the prosecutor's falir for the dramatic has actually obscurred the REAL crime in this case by focussing the attention on the last hours before death thus obscuring what CAUSED the death! The baby was very premature and born 4 months early and irreversably brain damaged as the result of a drug overdose administered at another hospital (Karolinska) - by the time the baby arrived at Astrid Lindgrens the chances of survival were zero:
- the overdose that caused the brain damage in the first place - resulted in a 'warning' for the nurse
- the doctor who possibly eased the pain of the dying baby gets charged with manslaughter
Is this logical?
Hmmmm.........You bring up some interesting points, but there is a huge ethical and legal dilemma here.
The parents are the legal guardians of the baby. Did they consent to the euthanasia? Or, did the doctor take it upon himself to terminate the life of the child?
Is there anyone on this blog that believes that a doctor should be able to perform a procedure on a patient - any kind of procedure - without proper informed consent??? No less euthanasia???
There are standards to determine when a patient is brain dead, or in a persistent vegetative state. The determination must then be confirmed by a second doctor. Only then can a doctor and responsible guardian(parent/husband/wife) make a proper decision about end of life.
I have no doubt that this doctor(assuming guilt) acted altruistically. Nonetheless, if this baby was euthanized without following proper procedures, it meets the legal standard for manslaughter.
I agree that the doctors should be trusted to make judgements and to prosecute them for their decisions is wrong. Especially here where the outcome was the same. Is this a ploy for money on the part of the parents or just a government official out for glory?
Irrespective of how bad the child's situation was, the doctor is required to follow proper precidure and HAS TO BE CLEAR about what she is doing- You just can't take things into your hands no matter how right you believe you are. She crossed the line. She probably presumed too many powers in her hands than she really has.
The child may have been bound/destined to die. Yes, but let her die the right way and with dignity. Do not hasten her death. DO NOT PUSH HER OFF THE CLIFF.
For some people like myself, euthanasia dehumanizes the human person. For example, I just can't think of memorial ceremonies for a euthanised person.
Doctors always prescribe stronger medicine to provide patients with terminal problems and severe chronic pain to ease the agony and comfort them ...... and give patients peace and relief from pain .... dignity for their last days ... often without need to seek consent from anyone...... often the best medical judgement of the doctor.... which included a painless last few days or weeks of life...........
Personally if i am in severe pain in my last days i wish a doctor will pump me with barbiturates and opiates and make my last days a pain free euphoric state....
If i am the parent , i would be thanking the doctor for going out on a limb to end the suffering of the baby I love..... love is dignity, a life that is productive and happy, a life without pain and sadness..... a life full of potential..... not a life bedridden with a severely damaged brain, tubes, nappies, bed sores, smell, etc............
@ G kin ...... if euthanasia dehumanize the human person ..... would a life totally spend in bed, unaware of everything around you, fed through tubes, body that is bones and skin and little or no muscles, without any communication skills (this is a baby) with all bodily functions aided by a group of nurses and personal aids, etc.... where everyone have feelings of sadness and pity only, ....... will the memorial service or burial at the end of a sad and miserable life be a real memorial ceremony or a real relief for those who are living and left behind ? ... and what would the memory of the baby be?
So you do not want to hasten her death ... and let her suffer a long and lingering definite death ...... I would rather be pushed off my suffering and pain and be in a less painful state.....
It would have been easier for all doctors to do nothing ... to do nothing to relieve the pain and suffering ...... but it is a doctor's obligation to relieve pain and suffering..... especially knowing that the baby will suffer severe pain and suffer ....
It is not just the qualify of life for the victim (baby) but also for all the living persons whose lives will also be affected.
Maybe those who felt guilty for the state of the baby needed to shift the blame to the doctor.... in order to relieve guilty off their own minds....
You probably did what you think was the right thing to do as a doctor for the baby who was suffering ... I salute your compassion because there is nothing personal to be gained for yourself ...by your action.
As a doctor, you can sleep at night knowing that you did the right thing for the baby ... but you might not be able to sleep much now, because of the actions brought on by those who wish to see the baby suffer in pain for whatever short life she might have.
Good Luck and hope that the judges see the selfless act you did.....
Maybe the doctor should have gone to court and seek the judges' direction as to whether society would like to see the baby suffer in pain or whether the doctor or hospital should prescribe a dose of pain killer ... a dose which could both relieve the pain or possibly result in a painless death at the same time.
We must ask ourselves a question:
What is to be gained by the doctor personally for prescribing that dose of pain killer?
If the answer is NOTHING..... then the doctor is not guilty.
You are missing the critical point here. A doctor does not have the right to make this decision, even if his/her motives are pure. In this particular case, the baby had parents who are responsible to direct the medical care of their child.
For the sake of argument, let us assume that the doctor is guilty as charged. To make the argument more interesting, let's assume that the parents would never have given permission for the baby to be euthanized, but wished for everything to be done for the baby. Do you still think the doctor had the right to take this baby's life?
And, let's make it more interesting still. Let's say this doctor feels very strongly about preventing suffering, and a review of the medical records show that 50 other baby's have died suddenly while under the care of this doctor - all 50 deaths without proper consent and without following guidelines. Do you still think this doctor is an angel of mercy?
I never said that the doctor intentionally ended the baby's life........ admittedly what i wrote may lead you and others to think so.
When the baby is at that precarious stage between life and death, and becos of the baby's fragile physiological state, and this apply to people with serious illnesses as well, it is very difficult to determine the highest dosage that is optimal to relieving pain and the dosage that could be fatal.
The doctor could continue administering a low dosage and let the baby suffer pain and let sleeping dogs lie ....... or make an effort to provide the patient maximum comfort .... which means administering the highest dose possible.... and that does could be fatal.
The doctor never take a decision to give a fatal dose..... but to provide the highest dose possible......
If the doctor ask the parents which is the maximum dose they will allow to give to babies ... then we dont need the doctor ... who is supposed to use his judgement.
The bodily functions are near a stand still and any dosage could be fatal.
Again I emphasize, the doctor did not intentionally give a fatal dose to commit euthanasia .... but the high dose to relieve pain ... may or may not have caused the death. That is just a fact.
A doctor stationed at a terminal ward where most of the patients are near death are likely to have a lot of deaths occurring under his watch... that doesnt mean he killed them all. He is neither an angel or mercy nor an angel of death.
If more people who commented here have spend time with people like that baby .... and with the dilemma facing the medical team caring for such patients ... maybe more will accept the fact taht medical care at end stage of life is ... like walking a thin line...
maybe care should be by committee at this stage.......to protect doctors from such charges.....
The prosecutor in the case somehow got wind of this and wanted to come in with the press as the savior of the babies from the doctor of death. Rather than serve the arrest warrant at the doctor's home, or do anything to make it non-disruptive, the prosecutor led a team of police into the middle of the hospital ward, while the doctor was on shift, ironically potentially putting other patients lives in danger. I know a pediatrician who feels quite threatened by this case that he has to choose between jeopardizing his freedom and career in order to actually treat his patients.
The prosecutor still believes this to be a career making case into politics and the public eye. They won't or can't back down now, especially since they originally got the media focused on them about how wonderful they were to catch this case.
The doctor was not trying to euthanize the child, she was just trying to provide it the necessary amount of drugs to actually make it comfortable despite the tolerance it had developed to pain killers.
I certainly agree with you that the intention of the doctor is critical. If the dose of pentothal and morphine were reasonable, then the doctor should be given the benefit of the doubt. However, if the dose indicates that the doctor intended to end the life of this child, his/her actions are indefensible.
I would like to point out two things:
First, many of the elderly with terminal conditions such as cancer have severe pain that requires aggressive therapy, I do not believe that neonates with severe brain damage have a similar source of pain. So, I am not sure of the role of morphine here except perhaps to help with sedation.
Second, I am not at all clear as to why pentothal was used here. Pentothal would not be used for routine sedation. Perhaps the child was placed in an induced coma with pentothal to reduce brain swelling. If that were the case, then there would be no need for the morphine because the child would already be comatose from the pentothal.
The facts of the case will speak to the intentions of the doctor.
A normal pregnancy is about 38 weeks.
This baby is 15 weeks premature, i.e. she was 23 weeks old when she was born.
... and she had severe brain damage and so on on top
The upper limit of legal abortion is 24 weeks.
That means that abortion doctors kill babies older than this girl... so legally this doctor is not killing 'anything' ... if the doctor is found guilty of killing this baby of 23 weeks, then all abortions of 24 weeks is murder or man slaughter. Interesting thought.
Interesting thought isnt it?
Lets consider another issue: brain damage.
I think more than half of us taking part in this discussion suffer from some form of brain damage due to alcohol or were born half witted.
Now this baby suffered from hemmorrages to both sides of the brain .... meaning that she will be a few times more stupid than most of us here. If we think that half of us here should be euthanized, ....... what hope is there for this poor girl?
THINK!
The outcome of the above trial is to spread fear in doctors about the use of pain killers. To be in the safe side doctors would give patients the minimum amount of pain killer, which might not be adequate enough to supress the pain!
There are many major malpractices in the hopital that are often ignored, e.g., not listening to patients' compalaints, careless diagnosis of diseases. This is where the authorities should focus, rather than on a none existing crime.
No doubt that patients in pain require aggressive therapy. But, we are not talking about an adult patient with cancer pain.
Tell me, what is the source of pain in a brain damaged neonate? Why large doses of morphine? Why Pentothal?
Makes me wonder.
If they was going to charge the doctor for what she did, they should also charge the police, the governors, and the government. What ever happened to "eugenics", where part did it come in on the situation. Eugenics is the study and practice of selective breeding applied to humans, with the aim of improving the species. In a historical and broader sense, eugenics can also be a study of "improving human genetic qualities." Advocates of eugenics sought to counter what they regarded as dysgenic dynamics within the human gene pool. Specifically, in regard to the continuation of congenital disorders and factors impacting overall societal intelligence relating to the heritability of IQ. (wikipedia)
There are many points I have to say since they are bringing this topic to the light.
To brings in the open there are many babies in the Dallas Metroplex being born with eczema (very very very dry skin). Children in poor communities cannot get the proper care for the skin disease and doctors say there is no cure. Is there a cure for anything?......
Children are also getting lead poisoning from toys and playing in dirt. In the west dallas area parents received money because their children was mentally unstable because there was lead in the dirt in the 1980's and early 90's.