Published: 12 Apr 12 13:46 CET | Print version
Online: http://www.thelocal.se/40228/20120412/
An Uppsala University official has promised to bolster efforts to give foreign students accurate information to help avoid misunderstandings like the one that has left one graduate student without her degree.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
The European Commission opened an in-depth probe on Wednesday to see if state aid given to Scandinavian Airlines by Sweden and Denmark conformed to EU rules. READ () »
In The Local's new Fashion Fix column on Swedish trends, Englishwoman Victoria Hussey gets up close and personal with shoes - namely "brothel creepers" from WWII that have been making a steady return to Stockholm pavements. READ () »
Imported frozen raspberries should be boiled before eaten according to new advice from Sweden's National Food Agency, which warns that the berries may carry the novo virus that is more known for causing winter vomiting disease. READ () »
A deceased patient who had no relatives was left in a room for five days at the Örebro University Hospital before staff realized the body was still there. READ () »
Stockholm bus traffic was at a standstill Wednesday as drivers launched a major strike at midnight, but a group of Conservative youths disrupted the action by replacing a bus route between two of the city's major hospitals. READ () »
Sweden Democrat MP Kent Ekeroth has to pay tax for money sent to his bank account as donations to two far-right websites that he claims to have nothing to do with editorially. READ () »
For some foreigners living in Sweden, a natural "inner Swede" can develop that often doesn't show its face until you're back home again. The Local's Patrick Reilly lists the top ten ways this inner-Swede can change your life. READ () »
Far-right websites in Sweden are receiving so much traffic they are seven times more popular than the established political parties' online portals. READ () »
| 18/06 | Accounting SpecialistHays | Katowice, SLA |
| 18/06 | Agency General Manager ? Scandinavia | Göteborg |
| 18/06 | C++ Developer | Stockholm |
| 18/06 | Chemical Plant ManagerThe Valspar | Hendrik Ido Ambacht (NL) |
| 18/06 | Cloud ArchitectCapgemini Sverige AB | Malmö, SKÅ |
| 18/06 | Compliance Manager - NordicsAce European Group Ltd | Stockholm |
More news from Germany at thelocal.de
More news from France at thelocal.fr
More news from Norway at thelocal.no
More news from Switzerland at thelocal.ch
Register now for:
> Free use of noticeboard
> Special discounts
> Weekly news roundup
> Unlimited use of discuss
This weeks results..week 24/25 »
"A weekend full of surprises and LFC football. Results look like this: Div 5 Men won 4-2, K1 lost 5-0, K2 won 2-1, Vets lost 3-2, R1 lost 4-1. Korpen Ladies play Monday night and on the 26th the Div5 Men close the first half season with the last match before the summer kicks in. /LFC " READ »
Your comments about this article:
The comments below have not been moderated in advance and are not produced by The Local unless clearly stated. Readers are responsible for the content of their own comments. Comments that breach our terms and conditions will be removed.
It's not a difficult piece of programming to write. Indeed I've just set it as a practical second year undergraduate computer science coursework assessment. Some trivial tree traversals, breadth-/depth-first. A little boolean matrix algebra. Hey presto problem solved. For extra grade put in a class estimator will you pass, with merit, or with distinction. A more refined version, suitable for a third year (final year) extended project would be to create a small size expert system that will not only check whether the chosen modules make up a degree but that can also suggest alternative modules where there are missing or invalid choices. Again, trivial. Extra grade would be earned by recommending follow-on Masters or PhD study in the major discipline. Though it does require quantitative methods in order to make it all work.
Of course it needs for the student to actually PASS the modules in the first place.
Universities in Sweden encourage this also, because it channels the tax money into these institutions.
... and yet the course structure for this course - core and electives is explained in English on the University website
Don't agree with you completely actually. As a non-Swedish-speaking person at Uppsala University (graduate level) it has been made abundantly clear to me many, many times that I'm only allowed to include X credits worth of undergraduate courses in my degree. I guess it depends on the coordinator, and the level of communication about this issue differs from department to department.
In any case it seems logical that a graduate degree cannot be filled (excessively) with undergraduate courses. I feel sorry for the student(s) in question but a visit to the department administration simply to ask "can I do this?" would probably have prevented it all.
I agree with hipersons1. I am a Swedish speaking person at UU, but even I have problem sometimes getting information on eligibility for graduation. coordinators are different, some are nicer than others, and some just dont seem to know anything. in the past i have ran into the dept admin to ask abt stuff, unfortunately you dont always get any helpful answer.
IMHO, it would have been more fitting to use a picture of the University Hall, or the University Library.
back when I did my Master degree (not at a Swedish university but a British one) one module had both undergraduate and postgraduate students in the lecture hall at the same time. The difference was the depth expected in the students answere. Undergraduates could get away with brevity and waffle; postgraduates had to be expansive and precise.
@all
Let's not forget that this situation has arise because one specific student is making a fuss even after she failed her quantitative methods module twice, count them once, twice. The advice she should have been given was not "make it up with undergraduate courses" but "the bus leaves from over there, bye bye."
Have you studied or worked at a Swedish uni, ever? You cant compare the British system with Swedish.
Let me tell you something. In Swedish universities, over 80% of the students fail core subjects at least once during their program. This is not a statistical data, but something I sum up from my personal experience. I am a Swedish speaking student at Uppsala without having the need to do any re-exam, but so far I have yet to know more than a handful of students on the same level as me. For my program the heaviest course was organic chemistry. On the first try more than half of the attended students fail. Re-exams are just like the ordinary exam, you can score an A there even if you failed earlier. So the difficulty level of re-takes is seldom reduced. Sometimes re-exams are absurdly difficult, with a passing rate of 5% or even lower. If you want to give Eliana an F because she failed one subject, first you have to give F to the majority of Uppsala students. There are certain things with the Swedish uni culture that an outsider simply cant understand. The kind of advice you just proposed, thank god you are never gonna work as an academic advisor.
Thank god I haven't studied at or worked for a Swedish uni then. If the system is based on the antiquated idea that specific proportions of students should achieve a particular mark then I don't want to study or even work for a Swedish uni. And as an employer I will in future be more circumspect in considering job applications from candidates holding Swedish qualifications.
Exams need to be passed but the marks should be awarded on how many of the criteria the exam is set against has the student achieved. If the whole class gets 100% so what. If one student, Swedish or non-Swedish speaking , fails then to achieve those criteria then so be it, they failed; no one should have to fail with them.
There should be no "passing rate is 5%" mentality, with the exception of medicine where for the health and survival of patients only the best are good enough. If students can't pass the exam there are a number of reasons:
o the exam is too hard, if so it needs to be made easier or more sensibly the marking criteria need to be evaluated and adjusted to reflect what is feasible;
o the teaching is poor, if so the teacher needs to be sacked and a competent one brought in to teach the course;
o the course doesn't adequately reflect the examinable topic, if so then either the course needs to be changed or the student told to "hit the books";
o the student can't cope with the material, if so the student needs to evaluate their status and either change to a course that they can cope with or suck it up and admit they failed.
It is possible that all those reasons are true which makes for a slightly more complex problem. But just letting students retake exams on the off-chance that the weighting the next time is in their favour devalues the worth of the degree.
Education isn't about is this student better than that one? It's all about does this student know the material and can demonstrate their competency with it. That Eliana gets an F so other have to too is idiotic and unfair on the others. If that's what the university assessment culture is in Sweden then that culture needs to change.
Once again, you assumed too much and misunderstood a few important things fundamentally. The system, for instance, is NOT based on your antiquated idea. All you have said further strengthens my point that as an outsider to the system, you have very little understanding of how it works.
First of all, the retakes that you deem as something horrible, is not discriminated against in Sweden. The reason a student does the retake might be: the student couldn't attend at the first occasion of exam perhaps due to conflicting schedule: the student might have failed the first exam, or the student wanted an A, but got only B+, so he/she decides to improve his grade by going to the retake.
The retake is simply another exam for people who needs/wants to attend it. You can get everything from F to A on it, instead of only Pass and Fail as in other countries. On your curriculum, it won't say if the you got your grade from the first exam or the retake, it's the same thing. If the student shows competency in the subject, does it matter when he/she obtained the competency during the school time? In some uni you can do retakes as many times as you want, but if it's for improving your grade from something higher than F, you can only do it within 1 year of the original exam. However I think the regulation has shifted somewhat, in some program you can do two retakes. So in Eliana's case, she should have one more chance. Nobody would've known about her retakes if she passed. Unless she failed her second retake, one cannot say that she won't possess the ability of completing the specific course.
The only time when Sweden used proportion based grades were when we tried ECTS grades, an EU invention that lasted only during its trial period because everybody hated it. It's very similar to the curved distribution of grading in many top American universities. now you have not only attacked swedish schools, but condemned most of the ivy league colleges. will you give 2nd thots to their graduates too?
The 5% passing rate I mentioned was the result of occasional improperly difficult exams. Nobody wanted to set a passing rate of 5%, but in the end, 5% of students passed. It was unfortunate, but such events do happen occasionally. Ever heard of Cornell? the ivy least generous with giving out good grades but their students are still wanted. What I'm saying is not "Eliana gets an F so other have to too". I'm pointing out that you cant judge her based on one course. You dont know the system and you dont know the circumstances. The fact she landed a job before getting her degree diploma speaks for itself. looks like she doesn't need you to review her CV after all.
You are right it is not that hard, we used to have a system like that back at my university in mexico 12 years ago. it would even check the schedules to make sure you didn't have 2 classes booked in the same time slot and it would give you alternatives of whichever classes you could indeed take. After more than a decade you would think Sweden would have catched up to my "3rd world' country.