Youth centre worker and columnist Milad Mohammadi questions whether traditional Swedish behaviour is really all it's cracked up to be if it often means not helping those in need.
A few weeks ago I wrote about tripping over on the pavement, and how even with bleeding knees I didn't get help from anyone, in fact not even getting a single glance in my direction – which I felt people did on purpose.
Now it’s happened again, but to someone utterly undeserving of such treatment.
An older gentlemen on the train to
Uppsala wanted to buy a ticket but didn’t have a credit card. He asked the other passengers if anyone could pay for him and said he'd give them the equivalent sum in cash instead.
Nobody helped him. Nobody even looked at him.
You know that feeling when people just keep on walking, pretending nothing has happened?
Or when people’s first reaction to someone asking for help is suspicion. And how we ourselves have stopped asking for help simply because that fear of suspicion holds us back.
Or when people only care about their own time and their own lives?
I ended up paying for the old man’s ticket. It turned out we were heading in the same direction and we chatted for a while.
He told me how people don’t see him as human. He got upset.
I told him I was about to give two lectures that day in two different cities to about 600 teenagers.
I promised to tell them to see their fellow humans as fellow humans, explaining that holding talks is what I do best.
The old man’s face lit up; he looked happy.
Fuck Sweden, I thought to myself.
Fuck traditional Swedish behaviour, to be more precise.
What’s my conclusion here? That my country disappoints me.
Everyone’s gone through this – not only as a witness but as an active participant, when you notice that you act this way yourself.
We see people bickering in public and we just walk past. We see people hurt themselves and we just walk past.
We see someone who is sad and we just walk past.
We see a person without a home and we just walk past.
We see someone who simply needs help for whatever reason and for some reason we – just – walk – past.
When was the last time we acted like fellow human beings in Sweden?
We’ve become incredibly good at disengaging our responsibility to other people. We’ve disavowed that responsibility. Everyone is on their own, everyone keeps away from others.
Swedish culture has made passivity the norm.
We trust that society’s structures will carry the weight of that responsibility and that unburdens us.
The worst thing for me is seeing how people are fascinated by the few who actually do step in and help.
That Swedes are shocked when people help each other shocks me more than Swedes in general never helping.
That shock tells me that something isn't right. We have been indoctrinated to disengage.
We’ve become so good at disengaging that even those of us who complain about Swedish behaviour don’t truly break out of the pattern ourselves.
We call ourselves the Twitterati, talking heads, and star reporters à la Swedish House Media.
Therein lies the comedy (read tragedy). We judge people who behave badly but we don’t take the opportunity to think about our own behaviour.
We don’t judge our own passivity.
Or the passivity of our friends.
When someone we perceive to be on our side says something offensive we just let it pass. We pretend nothing happened. Or we make excuses for them.
And even though we might spread Martin Luther King Jr. quotes on our Facebook page with righteous pride, we find it hard to live up to his words: “The greatest tragedy of this period of social transition was not the strident clamor of the bad people, but the appalling silence of the good people”.
Swedes like to react when big bad things happen. But not when they happen in everyday life.
The problem is that a society is built up by the small things that happen in everyday life.
When we engage we’ll give money to distant villages in developing countries; we might sponsor a child; send an SMS contribution when charity galas take place following large-scale calamities.
We do not engage in everyday life and we do not care about each other.
Similar problems underline racism and discrimination. We don’t see it because we have good lives.
It's easy to distance yourself from a reality that you cannot experience in the same way that the victim of racism and discrimination does.
We don’t even get close because we live safe and secure lives that were given to us for free. Take note of the word free. The life that most Swedes have been given was given to them mostly for free.
The only people who rattle our cage are the Sweden Democrats.
It’s time to change the norm. We’ve discussed the need to be good Samaritans, but this isn’t the topic today. It’s about waking about and treating each other like human beings.
Honestly. What the hell are we doing, Sweden? Why do we even deserve to live?
I’m throwing down the gauntlet to you, you who are reading this right now: How do you act towards your fellow humans, if you’re totally honest?
Are you one of the people who just walks on by? And, if you’re totally honest, why?
Milad Mohammadi is a 23-year-old columnist for the Nyheter24.se news website, a public speaker, and a youth worker at Fryshuset in Stockholm.
This column was originally published in Swedish on Nyheter24.se. Translation by The Local.
Your comments about this article:
The comments below have not been moderated in advance and are not produced by The Local unless clearly stated. Readers are responsible for the content of their own comments. Comments that breach our terms and conditions will be removed.
I've tried so hard not to fall into this crappy pattern that I'm surely ridiculed for being open,alive in the winter and caring about my co-workers,friends and neighbours when they need some this as simple as lending my ear.Those would be the jealous ones,to be sure.
Thanks for the wake-up call Milad,I will monitor my actions a little more closely for at least the rest of the day...
Canada, the True North Strong and Free; where strangers greet each other in the streets, something hardly ever seen in Sweden...
I say Hej to everyone I meet in my neighbourhood. Strangely enough the young always reply and smile,. Keep working on it.
As an example, many times in different countries, it has happened for me to stand on cross roads or bus stations with my head in a map to figure out my position, and many times many people came from and helped without even being questioned by me. Some just came from and asked if I am lost, or need help! Most of the times, I shocked, or felt very suspicious to see somebody try to help without being questioned by me, never happened for me in Sweden!
In the point of view that I have lived in Sweden for very long time (luckily, I am not a Swede); somehow, I have received Swedish behaviors and way of looking to other people; so, I don't help if nobody ask me for help, not even if I see somebody needs help, and feel suspicious if somebody wants to help me when I am not asking for help!
A Swede does not want to be bothered. The rationality of a Swede is that I am paying tax, and paying lot of tax for everything should be fixed by the system. I am going out and demonstrate for human right, but don't like to have neighbors from a developing country (especially Africans!).
The Swede sits on top of the planet near the North Pole, keep telling the world what is wrong and right, how everybody should keep the peace, how human should measure the humanity by Swedish standards, how people in the world should vanish the poverty and help each others; when it itself has one the highest rate of arm dealing and weapon production, highest level of discrimination and unemployment between its own immigrants, open racism, segregation, underclass immigrants doomed to poverty for life time.
As for people, I only know my family, and they are great. Sure they are not like Spanish people, so lively, but they are certainly very warm, honest and good-hearted people, which, believe you me, it is really hard to find.
We love Sweden, but I suppose, like any other countries, it has got flaws, we have them too, you just have to check the news.
Swedish system is based on deception. Do you honestly think Sweden grants asylum to "selected" group of countries because they are so hurt by the war affected suffering people. NO! they want a second class- citizens for second class jobs! Why Sweden have not adapted a skilled migration scheme as other developed countries? Why Swedes are silent when Universities like Uppsala and Stockholm run sweatshops of PHD students?
Get real! face the facts!
On CTA trains we are constantly bombarded by people asking you to give them money because the lord saved them from crack, crank or some other drug or just give them money to feed their 14 kids. I never give money but I bought one a hotdog rather than give him money because they'll just spend it on drugs (the guy didn't seem happy when I said I'll buy you a hotdog at that stand either).
You try to avoid looking at the crazy people because once you make eye contact, they are all over you (that's how I ended up buying the hot dog, he followed me off the train and had become like Velcro).
If you take out your wallet and someone sees something they like they grab it and run, or they see your iPhone and the go "apple picking" (which is what they call it when stealing apple hardware - we've had people killed on the EL in iPhone robberies)
If you're in a big city, your best bet is to keep your belongings out of view.
Another touching episode was my friends from school, Fredrick and Anne louis took me to a shopping mall for winter wear(which i had none) and found the best for me even trying the shoes out while holding my feet. All this when I had just known them for a few hours.
will always love sweden and its people. Maybe they prefer to help people in need and not those who can help temselves
we have it in our power to do something about this - lend a hand, a smile, exchange a few words, offer a lift, hold open a door.
don't give up and we can change the more officious, stand offish facade that prevails. there is warmth underneath it just needs a little encouragement to come out.
An "activist" against discrimination making awful far reaching blanket generalizations about an entire nation of people.
This is so thick with hypocrisy and double standards it almost seems like a joke.
What generalizations can we make about you based on background Mr. "Muhammadi"?
The Swedes do not bother to answer a greeting upon entering an elevator or a room. It should not be surprising that react well in more compromising situations.
It was only when I wrote a small book that I came to know of their 'other side'. My book was a key to unlock the generosity and humane side of that nation. Yes, it was not only that all my hopes were washed away by my tears but more crucial was that all the whiteness was washed away from their exterior walls and I realized how wrong I was in understanding these so called kind and generous people from a country known for their kindness, respect, justice and 'teddy bears' worldwide. I must thank Google because of which I am/was able to get all information at the click of a button.
I wish that Swedish company read this email of mine and if they believe in values and principles let them acknowledge my letters and emails sent to them including this one.
Thanks a lot for publishing this article.
Beatrice Mendes
Everyone walked by, no offers to help. Finally someone stopped, asked her if she would like a taxi or an ambulance. It was a Turkish immigrant.
@indianivvaljo: No, Swedes don't mind their own business. They are possibly the world's greatest busybodies. It's all done behind those twitching curtains and checking out the websites where they can snoop into the neighbors' finances....''
Haters come in all colors, religions, political beliefs, nationalities.
And this has worked in Sweden better than any other country! In other countries, you have never fixed the structure hoping that a helpful man happen to pass by?! That is too unreliable and that would only work if you are not subject to prejudice!
Then I can comment on the examples:
- Being helped without asking is not acceptable in Sweden. They find it intrusive! So it is not strange that they don't offer it either!
- There are a zillion different ways of money fraud so it is not strange people cannot trust that cash for credit offer.
- A man bleeding on the street can get a free transportation and the required medication in the hospital. So what's the fuss?! People help in other countries since these services are not free there!
Check the link below for a video, showing how our daily actions can make a big difference in any society we live in.
I'm sure all of Sweden is sorry about Mr Mohammadi's negative opinions of Swedish culture.
Of course all cultures have positive and negative aspects. A diatribe focusing purely on the negative traits of the Swedes is just a rant - and not far from a racist rant at that. Anyone who lives in Sweden (or anywhere else) can write such bluster; I can write one for you now if you want the Local.
People who live here (except for poor Mr Mohammadi) know that Sweden is a fantastic country, and that Swedes are a fantastic people who, aside from a few peccadilloes, one accurately highlighted here by Mr Mohammadi, are extremely generous and tolerant; particularly to those of Mr Mohammadi's background. They deserve better than this.
Perhaps the Local's busy moderator might remember that racism is a two way street, that many people find it unacceptable going either way, and take a minute to consider if this should really have been printed at all.
What if I were to write a critique of one of those cultures? The Romani, or immigrants from Africa for example. What if I headed it "To Hell With Traditional Romani Behaviour"? What would I be? And what if the Local were to print it, what would it be?
This piece is divisive and unhelpful at a time when the Sweden Democrats are gaining such support. Take it down immediately.
I was a taken aback a few weeks ago when, on a train from Helsingborg to Malmo, sitting near the bathroom, I observed two small children join the end of a short queue. The younger child (around four years old) was visibly in dire need of using the facilities; his discomofrt was obvious and yet not one adult in that queue offered to let the child use the bathroom before them. It seemed strange! Maybe not? Is it just me?
Swedes do have a great many postive attributes and I enjoy spening time there but they can be an odd bunch! ;-)
Truly nauseating stuff.
Further more this kind of principles that you have wiil make life miserable. Be possitive my friend.
But i think its something about the system too Swedish system made it like just care about yourself and leave the rest because the system is responsible.. i think alot of people really want to treat human fellows as human fellows but something stop them doing that and that is SYSTEM... I have couple of examples.. i have helped a drunk guy and stayed with him for more than three hours in cold until the help came ( I am happy about that) now the case where people give up... I tried to help an old lady in buss as she were standing when all adults were sitting i asked the lady to take my seat but she rudely refused to take the seat and replied "Jag behöver inte".. then couple of days ago one old man was bleeding from his nose i tried to give him some papers to clean up the blood but he refused to take my paper and took his own paper that was a way dirty but somehow i kept looking at him if he needs any further help and then his gloves fell down and took it and handed him when he is done cleaning his nose but then he had no choice to take the gloves from me...
there are many other cases i tried to help specially old people but seems like they feel ashame to take the help..
so i think its wrong to blame all the people yeah but the system who made us so selfish to depend only on system than HUMANS...
Anyone with a little travelling behind them has witnessed this kind of reaction in EVERY biggish city in the world. I have.
I also have witnessed the opposite.
I think this would be fine to be directed to people in general, so we think about our own behaviour, but directing it to just one nation when we can see this happen every day, everywhere we go... just gives me the chills.
I was crying a lot on a restaurant precisely last week, and i had a very nice swedish woman sitting next to me hand me a package of kleenex. She smiled and just gave them to me. I gave them back once i calmed down and thanked her for her kindness. I am also pregnant and nobody moves a finger when i come in the bus and its full and i need a place to sit. It annoys me. But so what. This doesnt represent the whole of Sweden .
I am sick and tired of coming to the Local and reading about how bad Sweden is. If it is, then freaking leave, the world is big and we dont need more moaners here. I understand it is difficult for many, it is for me, but it was also when i lived in other places, including my own hometown. I really dont find it any different than typical behaviour in certain places.
Refering to Swedes as "not having human values at all" is downright disrespectful to the land you are living in. If you want to live among humans, then go elsewhere. I am happy living among the humans here, thank you very much. Its so sad, most of the people complaining about it know very little about swedes or have made NO EFFORT to integrate. I see this every day. Integrating in a new society takes a lot of time and effort from YOU, not from THEM. They are here and have their lives, why would they bother on YOU? You are the foreigner, make the effort. It does pay off, every inmiogrant i have talked to that has managed to integrate agrees.
So whaveter....
You are completely right. This happens everywhere and is definetly not something uniquely swedish. I would be suspicious towards anyone who bash an entire country and it`s population based on something so one sided.
Whatever, I´m not swedish and last sunday i got to experience something it doesn't happen in most places: people coming out in the snow form their cozy apartments, to help me dig up my car from under the snow. Perfect strangers. All swedes.
Yeah, they were very selfish (?)
When I travel by train, I always offer women help with their luggage to board the train: Behöver du hjälp / Får jag hjälpa dig (as they are trying to lift their suitcase up the stairs) ? the answer is always a quick and sound NEJ, followed by a pause and a change of mind to JA. I think Swedes are programmed to say NO to help because they think someone offering help wants something in return because they themselves normally don't help anyone. Why should they ? The government should help....
Having said that, I was offered help finding where I was on the map in stockholm by complete stranger without me asking for help and also once had a car follow me for 100 m and honking at me (I was on my bicycle) until he got out at an intersection and pointed out that my 100 kr was almost out of my back pocket !
The writer doesn't mean there are NOBODY out there helping, just that there OUGHT to be more people proactively looking out for each other. When I help someone, I re-live the moment and the feeling of helpfulness many times afterwards, so remember that next time you have the opportunity to help someone.
F*** traditional Swedish behaviour, to be more precise. Unquote]I think that many Swedes would say F*** you young man . But then as you are a journalist (columnist) people do not expect much common sense, but the usual vague generalities and snide comments emanating from such a pen.
What is surprising is that the Moderators are so busy censoring the texts here for profanity, yet allow you to write as you do. My advice, for what it is worth, is for you to either accept that you have been able to bring your family to this country, or take yourself to some other country that will meet your requirements, whatever they may be. Wide-sweeping generalities such as yours - well, they show just how far you will go to 'win friends and influence people'.
What makes the author the right person to call something traditional Swedish?
This article is just bla bla of a loser unhappy with being in Sweden and trying to find something to explain his misery. Anyone who has travelled accross the world has faced situations that perfectly fit so called "traditional Swedish behaviour" according to the author.
However, the reality is that there is a large percentage of Swedes who behave as if they live on a different planet. They avoid contact with any human being, they don't speak, they are just as characters in an Ingmar Bergman film. As one of the commenters above wrote, they are Swedes who have not being abroad and who, despite leaving in a global village era, have chosen to ignore what is going on in the rest of the world. They live as if it was only them who existed on the planet. And, surely, they won't offer any help. Sometimes, these people stare at you persistently (yes, they are curious), but as soon as they realize you spotted them they turn away. And when you say "hello" they start walking faster. Such a behavior I have never encountered in my life, and I have lived in 8 different countries.
Certainly, Sweden is not like a major European country when it comes to the percentage of the population who live as if they come from Mars. Such a behavior one would expect from villagers in an isolated village in the Amazon. But we are in Sweden, part of Europe! This, of all things, is the most surprising thing. Having traveled in almost every corner of Europe, and having certainly met weirdos, I can definitely say that the percentage of people who are afraid of human contact live in Sweden.
Someone told me that not long ago supermarkets in Sweden had only one kind of pasta, one kind of rice, one kind of tomato sauce; and that Swedes were only allowed to buy alcohol only one day a week; and that there was only one pharmacy, the state one. An explanation of the weird Swedish behavior could be that they were used to this life. (This is surprising because, even in Soviet Union, they knew there was a different way. But Swedes didn't. They believed, and still believe, that their country is the best.) This kind of restrictions would certainly make them uniquely different from any foreigner, anyone from any European country. Perhaps, then, keeping to themselves was a sort of protection for the kind of restrictions they were subject to (restrictions which, in comparison with any other free country [barring Saudi Arabia and Iran] still, to a large extent, exist in Sweden).
Swedes like technology. They should use technology, especially the Internet, judiciously: to learn how by exchanging smiles and hellos and by realizing the kind of shortages they have in their country are not acceptable. Swedes should learn how to raise their voice when needed. To become friendly and to become angry. Living in apathy is not, really, something that humans do, if one accepts the majority rule: that the rest of the world is more human than the large percentage of Swedes who have chosen to live like machines.
if we would criticize your traditions you would call us racist and intolerant.
Your rant is laughable. But let`s pretend for the fun of it that what you are saying is true, what`s your point? What if some Swedes have decided to live like that, are they less human because of it? Are they worth less? Are they inferior? Are they not as good? What`s your point?
Swedes may be inpolite or shy sometimes, but on the orther side, they do not kill their own children for marrying 'the wrong' man. And Swedes do not try to kill everybody that opposes their politcs, customs or faith. If a Swede express his dismay by suicide bombers killing civilians and women and children, or by the newsreels of men executed without a trail and dragged after motorcykless by cheering men - then our dear guests accuse us for blaiming and stigmatizing every person of the same faith. But they do no confront their conpatriots when they are accusing Sweden for not providing them with easy and well-payed jobs.
So maybe we can call it quits? We are inpolite, and our guests can go on living their life in our modern western democracy following the 1400 year old customs of a people living as shepherds in a patriarchal and theocratic clan society? We know very well by now, that it is we who must adapt to every stranger that knocks on our door.
Don`t be sorry, answer my question instead.
As far as those people complaining about the Swedes who didn't help people in their hard times, I personally experienced it.
In Stockholm, last year on new year Eve - A Swedish guy was too drunk and was fell down (might be fainted as he there wasn't any movement seen at all in his body) on tunnelbana( Metro Station) in snow of freezing cold on the platform outdoor, hundreds of passengers were getting ON and OFF from the metro but nobody dare to help him or informed the station staff at the ticket counter.
I did go to the staff at the ticket counter and informed them to take care of that guy and I am not Swedish.
Therefore, I would say, Swedish people(except those who are already helpful) should learn to help because their help can save someone's life!
Scandinavians like to think they are well-developed but money isn't everything. The cost of financial security is conformity and lack of independence. It is astonishing how many people are happy to pay such price without even considering pros and cons.
I'd rather be worse off but free than locked up in a golden cage.
A waste of article space, in my opinion.
I am an English person living in Sweden.
http://www.thelocal.se/44954/20121210/
Learn to put arguments forwardm the right to an opinion (a.k.a. freedom of speech) belongs to everyone, not just ethnic Swedes. And that Sweden is a charitable nation, nobody disputes that. This is not what Malid criticizes; on the contrary, Malid's Sweden is one that sits on a really high pedestal, that's why he finds it so hard to accept the indifference and cynicism of the people he encounters in his everyday life. And to all of you who have come here clutching a map in your hand and looking lost, do not confuse the friendliness of the Swedish people towards foreign visitors with what Malid is saying. There is no friendlier people to tourists on this earth other than the Swedes. As for those of you who are willing to extend a helping hand to a stranger on the street, my guess is that this column was not written with you in mind.
Well, Malid, congratulations on voicing your opinion and don't let anyone tell you that you are not entitled to one because you were not born an ethnic Swede or that grateful, indebted people have no right to criticize things or aspire to a better society. Your critique is absolutely valid, even if it is more a Stockholm phenomenon than a national one. We all must definitely try and create a more humane and more tolerant society. People must stop thinking that helping out a fellow Swede is intrusive. And if 1 person may find it patronizing that you extend a helping hand, 9 people will find it a lovely gesture and probably do the same for somebody else one day. Hopefully this will eventually help change norms. Let's all hope then that good old Stockholm will learn from how people are in other parts of the country. Afterall many Stockholmers ARE from other parts of the country so they need not search long for inspiration!
He might have a point but his argument isn`t valid. His opinion is based on a few single events and has no factual worth. When he then takes it a step further and calls this behaviour swedish it becomes laughable. He shouldn`t be ridiculed because of his looks or background but because of his generalization of Swedes behaviour.
100% true. This is why I've left Scandinavia.
Well done, and the more who think like you should do like you.
Then Sweden would be a happier place for the rest of us, Swedes included.
should rightfully cause indignation to any Swede!. The irony is it appears the author is Muslim(I hope I'm right)
and is is amazing how they say things against other people and even their own. Granted, Swedes has a lot of learn yet, and I hope the younger are always better than the older folks.
- You are slightly misinformed, for like 40 years ago when I was kid everyone ate mostly potatoes, then it was no need for hundreds sorts of rice and spaghetti and tomatoesauces then. And we can not buy alcohol in Sundays but all other days we can buy alcohol (though all days in week we can at restaurants and pubs of course), and now we have several pharmacies but they does not work better than our old state pharmacy.
I've helped drunk people get help on a cold Winter night, made sure an elderly woman were taken to hospital when she fell on an icy sidewalk, drove two small children to safety for free, one night around 3 am and was scolded for it by their lousy parents. I'm not looking for gold stars, only telling you that not everyone is as bad as in your two examples. There are many good samaritans out there, but most don't go around announcing it. I just wanted to give a few examples that have happened to me and there are thousands of stories from other people who've done the same. "Dra inte alla över en kam".