Sweden can learn from the US on climate

A number of important American visitors were descending on Sweden on March 30th to talk about climate change policy. Former vice president Al Gore was talking to European Commissioner Margot Wallström in Stockholm, while minister for the environment Andreas Carlgren was due to debate with Dr Harlon Watson, US Senior Climate Negotiator and Ambassador Michael M. Wood .

It is often hinted in the Swedish media that the American representatives are here in Sweden to learn from the successful Swedish example of how to reduce emissions of greenhouse gases.

By signing the Kyoto treaty in 1997, the European Union committed itself to reducing its emissions of greenhouse gases by 8 percent between 2008-2012 compared to emissions in the 1990 (mainly carbon dioxide, CO2).

Since then the EU has not been able to fulfill those goals. Economic growth, real and projected, combined with Germany’s decision to phase out nuclear energy and greater than projected coal use among member countries will likely leave the EU about 10 percent short of its Kyoto target. In the last 15 years the US has done as much as Europe to reduce emissions, but in a different way.

Since president Bush declared that “We Americans are addicted to oil”, the increased full market price has passed the magical limit of $3 per gallon (about half the price for oil in Sweden). But Sweden has created a far more dangerous addiction to oil taxes. As 80% of the price in Sweden is composed by taxes it has reduced the interest for finding marketable new technologies.

The US is investing in hybrid technology, new efficient motors and fuels like ethanol and synthetic diesel. The cost of these fuels is often 50% of today’s oil price. American industries are often based on technologies that use the CO2 for commercial purposes in industry, rather than Europe’s emitting and taxing.

A market that is not distorted by excise taxes is open for these new solutions. Investors see profitable ventures and new solutions. Europe is unable to introduce this because of the excise taxes on fuels. We may talk a lot at international conferences but the results are scarcer since our governments have become dependent on the revenues from oil. Clean technology in combination with economic growth has shown itself to have been a far more sustainable way to reduce CO2 emissions at lower costs.

Sweden produces its energy through hydroelectric and nuclear power . Major emitters in Sweden, like the steel, mining and petrochemical industries, have benefited from a highly developed product range and for a long time invested in advanced technologies for cleaning and reducing emissions of CO2. The high quality of Swedish iron ore has also helped the steel industry to reduce its emissions.

Sweden had thus very low emissions to begin with, but the decision to reduce emissions by 4% for the period 1990-2010 does not have an effect on the climate. It also increases energy prices in Sweden by 30-40% because of the emission rights system and the virtual oligopoly it created between the producers EON, Vattenfall and Fortum. Sweden achieves little at high costs, and could thus learn a good deal from the US when it comes to climate policy.

Waldemar Ingdahl, director of the free market think tank Eudoxa


How Sweden’s Sami reindeer herders are being forced to adapt to climate change

The indigenous Sami people have herded reindeer in northern Sweden for generations, but climate change poses a new threat to their way of life and livelihood.

How Sweden's Sami reindeer herders are being forced to adapt to climate change
Reindeer pictured near the northern city of Kiruna. Photo: AP Photo/Malin Moberg

Once, the lynx, wolverines and eagles that preyed on their animals were the main concern for reindeer herders as they moved them to find food in the winter. But now Margret Fjellstrom and Daniel Viklund, a married couple from Sweden's indigenous Sami community with hundreds of tawny reindeer, worry about a new threat.

Shifting weather patterns in northern Sweden are forcing them to go further afield to find grazing for their hungry reindeer, pushing up costs and taking more time.

Dressed warmly in jackets and ski pants against the minus 17-degree-Celsius (1.4 Fahrenheit) temperatures, the couple watched on a February morning as their animals pawed through deep snow for the lichen they eat. It's their main food source in winter on the hillsides near Sweden's Baltic Sea coast.

Back when snowfall like this was a regular occurrence, Fjellstrom's herder parents would follow the same migration routes year in, year out, stopping at tried-and-tested spots for food. But that isn't the case now.

“It can rain in January, it can snow in May, there's no logic to it any more,” Fjellstrom, 39, said, sitting with Viklund by their snowmobiles.

Photo: AP Photo/Malin Moberg

Between 1991 and 2019, parts of northern and eastern Sweden saw a rise in average temperature of nearly two degrees C compared to the 1860-1900 period, Sweden's meteorological institute said in a report. For several days in early January, temperatures in the north climbed about 10C more than normal, the institute said. And on January 2nd, three weather stations in central Sweden reported their highest temperatures for the month since 1971.

Unseasonably high temperatures cause the snow to thaw and freeze again when the cold returns, building up thicker layers of ice that prevent the reindeer from digging down through the snow to the lichen.

To ensure they will find food during the migration, the couple spends two months taking turns to scout out unfamiliar areas, before setting off with the animals. Moving the reindeer from their summer pasture now often involves navigating them around motorways, windfarms or hydroelectric projects. The journey this year took nearly twice as long as it would have done in predictable weather, Fjellstrom said.

The Sami have herded reindeer across areas of northern Sweden, Norway, Finland and Russia for generations and are thought to number between 80,000 and 100,000, with many living above the Arctic Circle. In Sweden, only the Sami are allowed to herd the animals, raised for their meat, pelts and antlers.

Fjellstrom and Viklund annually move their herd from Dikanas, a village 800 kilometres (500 miles) north of Stockholm, to the plains near Ornskoldsvik. They transport them first by lorry, then release them and follow by snowmobile, tracking them using GPS collars.

Viklund watched as the reindeer disappeared into the snow-dusted forest, before launching a drone with a speaker attached into the freezing air above. It allows him to keep track of the animals when poor snowfall makes travel by snowmobile impossible. He can also herd them on with recordings of his dog barking when they head to areas with little food or hazards like roads or windfarms whose turbine noise scares the reindeer.

“We're getting more and more days that don't look like this, the snow is just a few centimetres,” he said. “It's a way to adapt.”

Reindeer herding on the Vindelälven river. Photo: Grahame Soden

Concerned that the animals get enough to eat, the couple split their herd and asked Fjellstrom's cousin to move the other half. It's an added expense for 31-year-old Neila Fjellstrom but he understands the need.

The Sami peoples and their reindeer are especially vulnerable to the effects of climate change, according to research. 

A “warming climate alters the vegetation conditions and threatens the reindeer's wellbeing and access to food,” Finland's University of Oulu and its Center for Environmental and Respiratory Health Research said in a study last year.

Many Sami are more worried about fluctuating temperatures now, than encroaching infrastructure, said Gunhild Rosqvist, a Stockholm University researcher into the effects of climate change in mountain and polar environments.

“I think their awareness of their vulnerability has increased a lot,” she told AFP.

At the annual Sami market in Jokkmokk above the Arctic Circle in early February, thousands of Sami mixed with tourists, just weeks before the new coronavirus forced countries around the world to introduce lockdowns. Reindeer products were proudly on display, from steaming pots of reindeer stew to soft pelts and knives with handles carved from antlers.

“Reindeer herding has been practised for many hundreds of years and it's an important part of Sami culture,” Kjell-Ake Aronsson, a researcher at the local museum, said. “Reindeer meat is an important product. A lot of people are related indirectly to reindeer herding.”

Sweden's Sami parliament estimates around 2,000 people are directly dependent on herding the country's 250,000 animals for a living. Away from the crowds, young Sami activists, in traditional outfits embroidered in blues and reds, gathered for a “climate strike” attended by Greta Thunberg.

Fjellstrom and Viklund's 17-year-old daughter Alva also spoke at the event and hopes to become a herder herself. But the increased effort needed for herding reindeer now makes Viklund worry about the future.

“I want to give my children the opportunity to do it,” he said, the sun casting long, blue shadows across the snow. “Climate change could destroy that dream.”

By Tom Little/AFP