Italian ambassador criticises Tegnell for saying Sweden ‘should have done better’ than Italy

Italian ambassador criticises Tegnell for saying Sweden 'should have done better' than Italy
Swedish state epidemiologist Anders Tegnell has defended the country's coronavirus strategy, which has not included a lockdown. Photo: Pontus Lundahl/TT
The Italian embassy in Stockholm has criticised state epidemiologist Anders Tegnell after comments in which he said the Swedish healthcare system "should have done better than Italy" in its handling of the coronavirus pandemic.

Italian ambassador Mario Cospito stated his country's healthcare system was “unanimously considered among the best in the world” and that those working in it deserved “respect and admiration […] in Italy and abroad” in his response to a radio interview with Tegnell.

The state epidemiologist told Sveriges Radio: “We had really thought that in a modern, wealthy society in Sweden we should be able to protect our elderly. [We thought that] it didn't need to be as it appeared in China, and perhaps even Italy, where they have less resources for this, but that we should as a society be able to manage this better.”

The interview did not give further details about where Tegnell believed Italy had fewer resources than Sweden, with the next question in the published version referring to Tegnell's hobby gardening. The Local has contacted the Public Health Agency for clarification on any difference in resources.

In the World Health Organisation's ranking of international healthcare systems, Italy was judged the second best in the world, with Sweden ranked 23rd, as the statement from Italy's ambassador noted.

(article continues below)

See also on The Local:

Ambassador Mario Cospito also pointed out that Italy has 5,000 intensive care beds (in a population of 60 million), with capacity to create “thousands more” if needed. Sweden currently has around 1,000 intensive care beds, a figure which has doubled since the start of the coronavirus outbreak, and has maintained 20-30 percent available capacity in ICUs across the whole country. 

Swedish healthcare staff have however warned of unclear guidelines and that some patients needing intensive care are not receiving it despite there still being several hospital beds available in the region, prompting an investigation by the country's healthcare watchdog.

CORONAVIRUS IN ITALY:

“The challenge of Covid-19 is not a football game, nor are there opposing fans in the stands who hope for the victory of their team: it is a common and generational challenge to guarantee everyone's health,” the statement from Italy's ambassador reminded.

“No cases have been shown where care has been denied to the infected or the seriously ill. In addition, in Italy, there is a comprehensive structure of private hospitals and clinics ready to move in to offer support to the national healthcare system.”

It also noted that “no one has so far questioned the Italian national health care system in the fight against Covid-19”, citing support from the WHO, European Union, and European Centre for Disease Control. 

Elderly care facilities have been badly hit by the virus in both countries, and elsewhere in the world. In Italy, most care home deaths are not included in the official death tolls, and police have reported cases of neglect, lack of cleanliness, and “suspicious deaths” in care homes across the country.

In Sweden, the healthcare watchdog on Wednesday said one in ten of the more than 1,000 care homes it had audited showed signs of “serious problems”, including linked to hygiene or staff continuing to work despite suspected infection, while there have also been reports of elderly people not being offered oxygen treatment and intensive care.

Sweden's death tolls include deaths outside hospitals and in care homes but only where the patient tested positive for the virus before death; the country's per capita testing rate is one of the lowest in Europe but care home residents are in the top priority group for testing.


Member comments

  1. The WHO ranking of health systems is from 2000, and based on data from the late 1990s. Also, the ranking itself was highly controversial when it was released.

  2. I find Tegnell’s comments chock-a-block filled with stereotypical predjudiced ideas about Italians as dark, dirty people living in overcrowded conditions etc. Meanwhile the area of Italy with the worst outbreaks is one of the richest in Europe: https://ec.europa.eu/growth/tools-databases/regional-innovation-monitor/base-profile/lombardy

    If politicians should stay out of questions of science, then the “experts” should stay out of areas not in their purview. Tegnell’s mandate and (doubtful) expertise is in Sweden whereas the area of foreign relations, EU relations, and such certainly IS NOT any of his or Giesecke’s affair. The fact that the government allows him to be a blowhard repeatedly just tells you how ineffective and weak the Swedish government is. I find it hard to think of another country where a bureaucrat would act this way and not be shown the door.

    Tegnell himself has managed to sour relations with Italy, the UK, our Nordic neighbors, Germany, the US…among others. There are few countries he hasn’t disparaged in an effort to cover up his own incompetence, laying his full (covert-type) narcissistic behavior on display for the entire world. Adding to Sweden’s shame even further.

  3. It’s impossible how this individual tries to hide the deficiencies of his work behind issues experienced by countries hit by the contagion weeks before Sweden and with very different social setups.

    I’ll be honest, I’m Italian and this really struck home. But comparing the Italian situation only when it benefits their propaganda is just wrong.

    > Sweden doesn’t need a lockdown because of low multi-generational households compared to Italy and Spain
    > Sweden should have done better than Italy given the resources they have

    I wish he spent more time not playing roulette with our health and less trying to compare pears and apples.

Become a Member to leave a comment.Or login here.