Reply to this topic

Train punctuality a matter of definition

The Local
post 24.Feb.2013, 11:08 AM
Post #1
Location: Stockholm
Joined: 22.Dec.2004

The Swedish Transport Administration (Trafikverket) has claimed improved punctuality rates for Swedish trains - but it has also tripled the time for what counts as a delay, from five to 15 minutes.

In 2012, 97 out of 100 regional and commuter train departures were on schedule, compared to 87 out of 100 in 2011, according to the Swedish Transport Administration.

But the main reason behind the improvement seems to be that the Transport Administration changed the definition of delayed journeys.

Previously, trains that arrived five or more minutes late were recorded as delayed. Now, a train can be up to 15 minutes late without being counted as late.

Click to read the full article.
Go to the top of the page
post 24.Feb.2013, 01:01 PM
Post #2
Joined: 9.Sep.2010

Noone that needs to be on time would take a train here, if there were any alternative at all.
Also, as a sidenote from Wikipedia:
"Japanese railways are among the most punctual in the world. The average delay on the Tokaido Shinkansen in fiscal 2006 was only 0.3 minutes. When trains are delayed for as little as five minutes, the conductor makes an announcement apologizing for the delay and the railway company may provide a "delay certificate" (遅延証明書), as no one would expect a train to be this late. "
Go to the top of the page
post 24.Feb.2013, 01:31 PM
Post #3
Joined: 10.Sep.2009

'Transport Administration changed the definition of delayed journeys'
Simpler than actually working hard to make trains run on time.
The Stockholm-Uppsala service is rubbish - and 15 minutes late on a 35-40 minute journey is substantial.
Trains are cancelled almost at random and even the tiniest layer of snow seems to be a problem. They have even cancelled the last train of the day without offering any alternative.
Go to the top of the page
johan rebel
post 24.Feb.2013, 04:13 PM
Post #4
Joined: 26.Apr.2011

The difference is huge. A fifteen minute delay is often sufficient for me to miss my connection, which results in a total delay of 1 or 2 hours, depending on when the next ferry leaves. So much for being "on time".
It is pretty obvious that Mussoline never ruled Sweden.
Go to the top of the page
Max Reaver
post 24.Feb.2013, 09:14 PM
Post #5
Joined: 26.May.2011

I totally agree with post #1. Having lived in Japan myself, if on the time table it says there are two minutes between two connections, you will have enough time to catch your trains. In Sweden it's not even sure with 15 minutes between two trains.
The Swedish railway system is pathetic, not only on matters of punctuality. In China, during one month around the Chinese New Year, the country's transportation has to move 2 billion people across the nation so they can reunite with their extended family over holidays. Most of them travel by train. Think about what kind of responsibility the government has. No matter what, the trains must run. I won't say you shouldn't criticize the Chinese government, as most ppl in west are indoctrinated to do. After first-hand experience of the transport-intensive one month, I'd say no democratically elected government so far has shown the same capability as the Chinese on this. The Swedish one has failed by far, every winter the trains stop and nobody takes responsibility. The Swedish minister of infrastructure has even hinted that ppl should celebrate Xmas with family another year. If a Chinese politician dares to say anything similar, there will be protests and riots in the streets. Here in Sweden, nothing.
Go to the top of the page
post 25.Feb.2013, 12:16 AM
Post #6
Joined: 20.Sep.2011

It's only a train journey, you're late for work, it doesn't matter, the world hasn't stopped turning, chill out. Japan has pumped billions into transport, would you really want their level of debt?,
Go to the top of the page
Max Reaver
post 25.Feb.2013, 11:15 AM
Post #7
Joined: 26.May.2011

So you are implying that Japan can get rid off their debt by turning their railway system into more Swedish-like? What a comedian. It's not only about getting to work late (which has been shown to affect productivity), the most annoying thing is not able to go home and left starving for hours on the commuter train. Obviously you never needed to commute between e.g. Stockholm and Uppsala, where thousands of ppl get stranded on a weekly basis as soon as snow touches ground. Next time I get stuck on a train, you give me your car keys and take my spot on the train.
Go to the top of the page
post 26.Feb.2013, 04:21 PM
Post #8
Joined: 5.Jan.2013

I live in suburbs of London. When I moved to my home 5 years ago, the Scheduled time was 18 minutes to Paddington Station = all trains late = No season ticket discount.
The Next year, ALL trains were 23 minutes in time table for same journey - but still had a few delays.
Currently, the time table states THIRTY (30) Minutes for the journey - ie. ALL trains arrive ahead of schedule and therefore NO discounts. I am now paying 280% higher fare than when I chose my current home.
It is no longer economical to live where I live - compared to London prices when I have to pay £4500 per year for a Season Ticket!
It should also be noted, I was on a delayed departure from Paddingdon, 14 Minutes late departing, but because of the delay the Train was run at a Higher Speed, (it was capable of even higher), it arrived at my station - ONE minute before it was scheduled because it was driven at a Higher Speed.
The Line and the Trains are capable of >250kph but are run at less than
Go to the top of the page

Reply to this topic
1 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members:


3,458 Jobs
Click here to start your job search

Popular articles