• Sweden's news in English
 

'Migration net benefit ignored in heated debate'

Ann Törnkvist · 15 Jan 2014, 16:20

Published: 15 Jan 2014 13:12 GMT+01:00
Updated: 15 Jan 2014 16:20 GMT+01:00

Gothenburg University researcher Joakim Ruist looked at 4,000 Romanian and Bulgarian residents in Sweden in 2011. To remain in Sweden after a first three-month stint, nationals of the relatively new EU member states would have had to prove to Swedish authorities that they had a "reasonable possibility of finding work".

The households surveyed - 40 percent of the total population that moved here between 2007 and 2010 - were then analyzed in terms of income tax, employer fee contributions, and a calculation of expected VAT expenditure.

Ruist then looked at demographic data, using averages for the population at large - "for example how many days a 40-year-old man in Sweden spends in hospital and what it costs" - to deduct likely state expenditure from the equation. He also lopped off average pre-school and school costs for the children, and so on.

"It's quite a reliable methodology that has been used in many previous studies," Ruist told the The Local.

He said he might have exaggerated how much new arrivals cost Sweden in terms of infrastructure upgrades or even armed forces spending, but that he and other researchers would rather overestimate the cost rather than stand accused of downplaying the costs.

The Local: Why did you want to look at these numbers? 

Joakim Ruist: When I began this research the debate about social tourism was dead as a doornail, but once I reached the end of my research it had gained momentum again. And now this wild debate is focusing only on Romanians and Bulgarians even though the measures being taken affect all EU citizens. 

Why is the case of Sweden relevant when looking back at the 2007 EU expansion? 

Sweden and Finland were the only ones out of the richer EU countries that imposed no restrictions at all. Fifteen European countries in total decided to restrict access to citizens from the two new member states in different ways, making Sweden one of the two possible examples to look at.

Ten years ago there was reason to have the debate because we were facing something completely unknown. If someone hurled out a statement saying "X number of people will come and they will bla bla bla" then there was no basis for that statement.  But there was more reason to be worried.

Research has now been done in the UK, which shows there has a been a positive net contribution by the migrants from that expansion. Yet they still manage to be really worried about the effect on public finances. The UK debate has been decoupled from the facts that we are putting on the table. 

Do we know why?

Nobody has a good answer. Neither the journalists I've spoken with nor British researchers. OK, we have the financial crisis, but we've got that in other countries too. Nowhere has the debate become so very heated as it has in England.

Could it be motivated by anti-ziganism?

If it were, I'd say we would be seeing this debate in France and Italy, where anti-ziganist attitudes are probably at least as strong as in England.

Do the upcoming UK elections have anything to do with this?

The United Kingdom Independence Party (Ukip) has entered the stage, and while no one is particularly scared of them at home, because the UK has first-past-the-post constituencies, they could rally their supporters to go vote in the European parliament elections. So few people vote that just a few passionate voters can make a big difference. 

Yet by focusing on Ukip, you're again pushing the question away. Why have they gotten wind in their sails now? And that's where you can say that no one really has a good answer. 

These studies about migrants' net contribution, should they matter? Should Sweden ask how much refugees from Syria contributed in five or ten years' time, for example?

In general, I think the criticism you give voice to is relevant, but in this study we were looking at a very specific discussion about what migration after EU expansion would mean for our welfare. It made it very relevant to look at the numbers and ask, 'Did this cost us?' and to be able to say 'No, it didn't'.

Story continues below…

I think it is considerably more questionable to ask questions about all immigrants. We've had different policies across 70 years of immigration, so which specific political question would you be trying to answer?

What would you do with the information, what would you use it for? It does cost money to receive refugees - no one has claimed differently - but we don't receive refugees to make money.

However, if someone started referring to totally wild figures about immigration and it affected the debate, then I could consider having a look at the figures myself to make sure the debate was factual. But that's a hypothetical future situation. 

Going back to your recent study, do the immigrants whose income you surveyed earn the same as native Swedes? 

Looking at the distribution of incomes, it tips toward less-qualified jobs. On average, they earn significantly less than the average salary in the rest of Sweden. This is partly because I think many couples moved to Sweden together in the past one to four years, and sometimes only one partner finds a job.

There are also many people with children, so there are probably a few housewives... I don't think there are that many house husbands.

Ann Törnkvist (ann.tornkvist@thelocal.com)

Your comments about this article

Today's headlines
Video
Hello! This Swedish cover of Adele's hit will blow you away
This is the real Adele. Photo: Chris Pizzello/Invision/AP

Hello! This Swedish cover of Adele's hit will blow you away
1 hour ago

What would Adele sound like if she were Swedish?

Ski region top in Sweden for chlamydia cases
Ski tourists at one of the resorts in Åre, Jämtland. Photo: Pontus Lundahl/SCANPIX

Ski region top in Sweden for chlamydia cases
2 hours ago

It is only February and already 2,728 Swedes have been treated for chlamydia.

Lisa Holm murder
Swedish girl's killer loses case in appeal court
Lisa Holm was killed in Blomberg. Photo: Adam Ihse/TT/Police

Swedish girl's killer loses case in appeal court
4 hours ago

Nerijus Bilevicius still faces life in prison for killing 17-year-old Lisa Holm.

'Naive' Swedes are renting homes to Airbnb hookers
File photo of a couple in a Swedish apartment. Photo: Sandra Qvist

'Naive' Swedes are renting homes to Airbnb hookers
5 hours ago

Is that respectable-looking couple subletting your apartment actually too good to be true?

Sacked Chelsea boss says he could 'not survive' in Sweden
José Mourinho in Arjeplog, Sweden. Photo: Gestifute

Sacked Chelsea boss says he could 'not survive' in Sweden
6 hours ago

What's José Mourinho's problem with Sweden?

Refugee crisis
Immigration concerns swell among Swedish voters
Refugees in southern Sweden in December. Photo: Johan Nilsson/TT

Immigration concerns swell among Swedish voters
6 hours ago

40 percent of Swedes now believe 'integration and immigration' is the biggest issue facing the Nordic nation, a new poll suggests.

Swedish teen beats cocaine stir with 'French kiss' defence
The people pictured are not related to the story. Photo: Claudio Bresciani/Sandra Qvist/TT

Swedish teen beats cocaine stir with 'French kiss' defence
7 hours ago

You may snort at it, but a Swedish appeals court bought this defence hook, line and sinker.

Beyonce slots Stockholm into Formation world tour
Beyonce at the US Superbowl. Photo: Matt Slocum/TT/AP

Beyonce slots Stockholm into Formation world tour
11 hours ago

The Crazy in Love star is heading to Sweden in July.

My Swedish Career
'I was pretty lucky, I sort of just walked into it'
Scott Wallace is manager at a juice bar in Stockholm. Photo: Emma Lidman/The Local

'I was pretty lucky, I sort of just walked into it'
11 hours ago

Scott Wallace moved to Sweden in October 2014. Today he runs a busy juice bar in one of Stockholm's trendiest areas.

Man dies after falling four floors in Swedish nightclub
People queuing outside the Yaki-Da nightclub in Gothenburg last year. Photo: Yaki-Da Facebook

Man dies after falling four floors in Swedish nightclub
2 days ago

A man in his 30s has died after falling from the fourth floor inside the Yaki-Da nightclub in Gothenburg late on Friday night.

Sponsored Article
How to set up shop in the 'Silicon Valley of Sweden'
Culture
Ten fab Swedish hits for February
Sponsored Article
US taxes and FATCA: 'The time for hiding is over'
Finest
Gallery
People-watching: February 6th-7th
Lifestyle
VIDEO: What's the fuss about Sweden's semla bun?
Blog updates

5 February

Editor’s blog, February 5th (The Local Sweden) »

"Hello readers, A friend of mine wrote from abroad this week to ask me if international media…" READ »

 

4 February

City Runs (The Diplomatic Dispatch) »

"Since moving to Stockholm I’ve been blessed to live next to the Djurgarden, and to be…" READ »

 
 
 
Sponsored Article
Swiss hospitality: The ladder to your international career
Travel
Stockholm's eight REAL no-go zones
Sponsored Article
Ice magic at north Sweden island lodges
Gallery
People-watching: February 3rd
National
'How confronting the man who robbed me gave me closure'
Analysis & Opinion
DEBATE: Why are Swedes so obsessed with Nordic skiing?
Sponsored Article
Just landed? Here's the secret to finding work in Stockholm
Culture
See which Swedish museums are now opening up for free
Sponsored Article
Stockholm's secret ski resort: Kungsberget
Gallery
Property of the week: Insjön, Nacka
National
VIDEO: Tensions caught on camera inside Swedish asylum home
Sponsored Article
Luleå: 8 winter must-dos in Sweden's far north
Gallery
People-Watching: January 29th - 31st
International
How will Sweden deport up to 80,000 failed asylum seekers?
Sport
When you gotta go... Swedish racing dog does poo and then takes gold
Sport
Guess who just got a HUGE pay rise?
Travel
WATCH: Five top tips for safe ice skating on Sweden's gorgeous lakes
Gallery
People-watching: January 27th
National
'Sweden could be at war within years'
Gallery
Property of the week: Öjersbo, Kungsbacka
International
Why is the Pope coming to Sweden?
Travel
Ten must-see Stockholm museums
National
He created Sweden's huge snow penis
Culture
The historic moment when Abba reunited on stage in Sweden
Analysis & Opinion
OPINION: Why I can't embrace Sweden's obsession with hugging
3,425
jobs available
PSD Media
PSD Media is marketing company that offers innovative solutions for online retailers. We provide modern solutions that help increase traffic and raise conversion. Visit our site at:
psdmedia.se