• Sweden's news in English

Jehova's witness loses Swedish tax fight

Ann Törnkvist · 16 Jan 2014, 09:34

Published: 16 Jan 2014 09:34 GMT+01:00

While a person living in a convent or monastery with no duties beyond his or her membership in that religious community has not needed to pay tax in Sweden, a new ruling has said about one hundred Jehova's Witnesses living in Arboga should be considered as employed.

"With the very broad definition of what constitutes employment nowadays, the circumstances cannot, according to the Tax Committee (Skatterättsnämnden), be judged in any other way than the commitments are to be considered employment," stated Sweden's Justice Chancellor (Justitiekanslern - JK), which upheld both the tax agency's and an administrative court's earlier rulings.

The lawyer representing his fellow Jehova's Witnesses had referred the case on to the Justice Chancellor because he believed that having to pay income tax on housing, board, and pocket money violated their rights as defined by the European Convention on Human Rights. In particular, the congregation referenced articles nine, the right to freedom of thought, conscience and religion, and 14, the prohibition of discrimination. 

The Swedish Justice Chancellor ruled, however, that there had been no religious discrimination.

The lawyer at the centre of the dispute had double-checked with Sweden's tax authorities in 2009 to see if the residents at the centre were exempt from income tax. Due to a perceived lack of clear legal precedent, the case was looked at by Skatterättsnämnden, a state agency linked to the finance ministry that issues binding recommendations in cases where neither legislation nor previous cases shed light on how to proceed.

Story continues below…

The committee members ruled that the Jehova's Witnesses living at the centre were not exempt. One committee member objected to that ruling, however, stating that he considered that the plaintiffs' living circumstances were similar enough to living in a nunnery or monastery. Nuns and monks have so far been exempt from income tax duties, although the committee member also noted that Swedish tax law had been updated and no one had taken a look at the tax situation of the monasteries under current law.

"There is an established administrative precedent," the committee member argued. "As long as the person's situation and income are comparable to situations that have previously been covered by that administrative precedent, he has a right to be treated the same way in terms of taxes."

Ann Törnkvist (ann.tornkvist@thelocal.com)

Your comments about this article

Today's headlines
Why I bared my breasts for a school photo
Photo: Private

“I think it’s a social construct that we should think of breasts as such a big deal.”

Watch out for rail delays this holiday weekend
Photo: Nora Lorek/TT

Make sure you bring plenty of entertainment if you’re taking the train between Sweden’s two biggest cities this weekend.

Weary asylum seekers choose to leave Sweden
Police supervise a queue of asylum seekers at Hyllie station near Malmö in November 2015. Photo: Johan Nilsson/TT

Year-long waits are one reason.

Disgraced celeb surgeon defends work in first interview
Paolo Macchiarini. Photo: Lorenzo Galassi/TT/AP

Scandal-hit Italian surgeon Paolo Macchiarini is accused of using Swedish patients as guinea pigs.

The Local List
Nine startling ways Sweden's capital will steal your heart
Living in Stockholm isn't all about Abba and meatballs. Photos: Hasse Holmberg/Anders Wikström/Christine Olsson/TT

It's easy to fall in love with Stockholm's architecture, parks and sense of style. But there are so many more reasons to be passionate about the stunning city.

Couple terrified after new tenant bakes hash cake
This gingerbread cake is perfectly innocent. Photo: Fredrik Sandberg/TT

He doesn’t Iive with them any more.

Fury as sacked boss gets job with migration agency
Angeles Bermudez-Svankvist in 2011. Photo: Janerik Henriksson/TT

“People were screaming in the corridors.”

Police resources back to normal after terror threat
The headquarters where Säpo, Sweden's security police is based. Photo: Fredrik Sandberg/TT

Swedish police say they're no longer deploying extra resources following a reported terror threat in the run-up to Eurovision.

Why this fearless woman is the talk of Sweden
Photo: David Lagerlöf/Expo/TT

Swedes are calling this picture an instant icon.

'Swedes, please give your sperm a purpose'
File picture of an embryo. Photo: Richard Drew/AP

Swedish men should stop jerking off in public places and start donating sperm to help single women have babies, argues Stockholm-based writer Matilda Karlsson.

Sponsored Article
The Inner Circle: Stockholm's secret dating scene
Eurovision heads to the US (kind of)
Sponsored Article
Eat, learn, live: unforgettable holidays in France
Sweden set for sunny weekend
Property of the week: Vollsjö, Sjöbo
Blog updates

29 April

Editor’s blog, April 29th (The Local Sweden) »

"Hello readers, Relations between Sweden and Russia went from slightly strained to full-on James Bond this…" READ »


18 April

A day as a guard (The Diplomatic Dispatch) »

"Life as an Ambassador. Driven around in the Jaguar. Visits all planned so you go straight…" READ »

Sponsored Article
Kista: The best office space in Sweden?
How to be a cool Swede during a hot summer
Sponsored Article
'Swedes must realize only soft power can defeat radicalism'
People-watching: April 29th - May 1st
Analysis & Opinion
Why Sweden's fretting about Brexit
INTERVIEW: Swedish police officer 'beat me up and used racial slurs'
Sponsored Article
How to launch your international career
People-watching: April 27th
Sponsored Article
Becoming an expat: where to start
Öresund bridge border checks net record number of drink drivers
Swedes bid farewell to iconic Volvo
Sponsored Article
Why international researchers love to call Malmö home
Property of the week: Enköping
Sponsored Article
How Stockholm startups help new employees feel at home
People-watching: April 22nd-24th
Could Brits in Europe stop Brexit?
Sponsored Article
‘Life in Stockholm’s suburbs is better than people realize’
The first official picture of Sweden's new royal Prince Alexander
Sponsored Article
'I may work at a Swedish company, but we’re global'
Sweden's Sami reindeer still live in the shadow of Chernobyl
Sponsored Article
'A sustainable Sweden must embrace diversity'
People-watching: April 20th
Sponsored Article
What's the best way for expats to transfer money abroad?
Why was a Nazi flag hoisted in a Swedish town on Hitler's birthday?
Sponsored Article
Sigtunaskolan: 'The best of what Sweden has to offer'
How did Sweden's deputy PM get in trouble over New York comments?
Sponsored Article
'I may work at a Swedish company, but we’re global'
People-watching: April 16th-17th
Sponsored Article
The Inner Circle: Stockholm's secret dating scene
Sweden finally axes historic dancing ban
Have you phoned Sweden yet?
People-watching: April 13th
Is booze going up in Sweden?
jobs available
PSD Media
PSD Media is marketing company that offers innovative solutions for online retailers. We provide modern solutions that help increase traffic and raise conversion. Visit our site at: