• Sweden's news in English

'The concept of race is a slippery slope': Ullenhag

The Local · 1 Aug 2014, 16:33

Published: 01 Aug 2014 16:00 GMT+02:00
Updated: 01 Aug 2014 16:33 GMT+02:00

The decision has been more than 20 years in the making, Ullenhag said, and has been discussed extensively on both parliamentary and international levels.

 "I think we should have done it before," Ullenhag told The Local. "But at least we're doing it now."

The suggestion received unanimous support from the governing alliance of Sweden. On Thursday an investigation was launched into how best to implement the decision.

"First, we need to determine if we need something instead of race, a different expression," Ullenhag explained.  
He said that in many laws the terminology should be an easy fix - it will still be illegal to discriminate against ethnic background or religion, for instance. The government also needs to make sure the new Swedish law proposals are in line with international human rights conventions.
"There are many international conventions that use the word race, so we have to make sure we don't miss anything. The problem is that the word 'race' is used differently in different countries," Ullenhag said.
Sweden must ensure that the decision complies with the EU Anti-Discrimination Directive, which demands that EU nations provide protection against discrimination on the grounds of "racial or ethnic origin".
But Sweden's step, although seen by some as bold, is hardly ground-breaking. Austria has already "rejected the idea of separate races" and replaced the term race in legal texts with the term "ethnic affiliation", as is also done in Hungary. In French legislation references are made to "real or assumed" race, another method of watering down the term.
The minister explained that he, along with the Swedish government, desired to scrap the word "race" due to the way the term is used in Sweden - as confirmation that subspecies and "races" of human kind exist.
"The idea of race in Sweden goes back to race biology, and the research we had in Sweden back in the days when we were heavily influenced by Germany," Ullenhag explained. 
The Swedish Society for Eugenics (Svenska sällskapet för rashygien) was established in 1909, and in 1922 the Swedish National Institute for Race Biology (Statens institut för rasbiologi) was opened in Uppsala - the first such institution in the world.
The research institute was headed for nearly 15 years by Herman Lundborg, a physician with anti-Semitic views and an adamant advocate of "racial hygiene" and eugenics. Some have even said the institute inspired Nazi biopolitics.
The Institute later became associated with an sterilization programme for people with "negative" genetic characteristics - a programme which was not terminated until 1975.
In 1999 researchers with the Human Genome Project (HGP) determined that the idea of race has no roots in genetics.
"The concept of race disappeared from scientific discourse more than a decade ago," Juha Kere, Professor of Molecular Genetics at Karolinska Institute, confirmed for The Local on Friday.  "It is the broadly accepted conclusion based on worldwide genetic studies that the concept is unfounded."
Professors across the globe have come to the same conclusion, with American anthropologist Loring Brace writing that, while there are genetic differences across the world, there is no visible line, no clear-cut categories.
"As a rule, the boy marries the girl next door throughout the whole world, but next door goes on without stop from one region to another."
Kere explained that, while there are differences between populations, the genetic variation within each population is greater than the variation between different populations. 
"And more importantly," Kere said, "the differences between populations are gradual and reflect the spreading of all humans from Africa. We are all descendants of the early Africans. There are  no sharp differences that would in any way reflect the old 'race' definitions."
In other words, the Swedish government decided it's about time.
"It's quite an unmodern term," Ullenhag told The Local. "It implies that we do have different races, and modern science says that we don't."
But while there may be scientific consensus that "race" is indeed an outdated concept, there are those who say that the term still fills a vital function.
The National Afro-Swedish Association (Afrosvensarnas Riksförbund, ASR) has been particularly critical. 
"Race may be a social construct, but that doesn't mean it's not a reality," ASR spokesman Kitwamba Sabuni told The Local. "For us, this is just trying to take away the possibility to even talk about it. It's critical."
Zakarias Zouhir, chairman of the ASR, agreed.
"This path worries me," Zouhir told Sveriges Television on Thursday. "It's just sweeping it under the blue and yellow rug and pretending there is no racism in society."
Ullenhag responded by saying that the "collective" perspective of the ASR focused on "racification", the claim that "we are all stuck in our races". 
"I think that you are on slippery slope there. The problem with that view is that you lose individuality," Ullenhag argued. "I think a liberal way of fighting xenophobia is more effective, where you say that it is always unacceptable to judge people from a collective standpoint. They should always be treated as individual human beings."
Ullenhag stressed that racism and xenophobia will still be hit by legislation even after removing the word race from law. He admitted that, while scrapping the concept of race may not end racism, he believes it is a key "piece of the puzzle". 
"We need the political leadership to stand up for the equal value of all humans," Ullenhag told The Local.
"We also need to be crystal clear in Sweden that we will not follow the same path some EU nations have done by following xenophobic forces. Our government has been very clear that, yes, we do have a xenophobic party in parliament, but we will not let them change the political map."
Solveig Rundquist
Follow Solveig on Twitter

Related links:

For more news from Sweden, join us on Facebook and Twitter.

The Local (news@thelocal.se)

Your comments about this article

Today's headlines
Nordic Noir
New Swedish Wallander 'out of the question'
Kenneth Branagh in the UK TV version of Wallander. Photo: Yellowbird/TT

New Swedish Wallander 'out of the question'

27 minutes ago

Swedish writer Henning Mankell, who died on Monday, was adamant that his characters, including detective Kurt Wallander, should never be resurrected by a another writer, his publisher has said.

Refugee crisis
Sweden to welcome first 'relocated' refugees
Refugees activists gathered in Rome in June 2015. Photo: TT/AP/Andrew Medichini

Sweden to welcome first 'relocated' refugees

52 minutes ago

A controversial programme to relocate 40,000 refugees within the EU from overstretched frontline states is set to formally start on Friday when a group of Eritreans will travel to Sweden from Italy.

The Local List
Five cosy hotel bars in Sweden's cool capital
Many of Stockholm's hotels serve up cockails. Photo: Eric Risberg/TT

Five cosy hotel bars in Sweden's cool capital

2 hours ago

Hotels aren't just the preserve of tourists in Stockholm. They are also home to some of the hippest drinking spots loved by locals. Here's our pick of places to stay snuggly during autumn and winter.

Swedish lifestyle pulls in record foreign tourists
Tourists in Stockholm this summer. Photo: Christine Olsson/TT

Swedish lifestyle pulls in record foreign tourists

14 hours ago

The rainy summer did not stop foreign tourists from flocking to Sweden in record numbers, according to key statistics released on Tuesday afternoon.

The Local List
Five unique backpacker hostels in Stockholm
A room in Stockholm's Långholmen prison. Photo: Långholmen prison

Five unique backpacker hostels in Stockholm

November 19, 2014

From prisons and boats to renovated jumbo jets, Stockholm has some unusual backpacker joints. The Local's Oliver Gee - himself a seasoned traveller - spent a night at five of the top rated locations on review sites, to see if the hostels in his adopted home city lived up to the hype.

Greenpeace mulls Vattenfall plant takeover
One of Vattenfall's plants in Germany. Photo: Patrick Pleul/picture-alliance/dpa/AP Images/TT

Greenpeace mulls Vattenfall plant takeover

16 hours ago

It might sound like one of the environmental group's protest stunts, but Greenpeace insists it really does want to buy up a series of brown coal mines and plants offered for sale by Swedish power company Vattenfall.

Swedish striker confirms talks of Zlatan-the-movie
Sweden forward Zlatan Ibrahimovic. Photo: Janerik Henriksson/TT

Swedish striker confirms talks of Zlatan-the-movie

16 hours ago

Sweden's national star footballer and Paris Saint-Germain striker Zlatan Ibrahimovic confirmed on Tuesday that he is in talks to turn his life into a movie.

Nobel Prizes 2015
Who are the 2015 Nobel Physics winners?
Takaaki Kajita and Arthur B McDonald. Photo: Fredrik Sandberg/TT

Who are the 2015 Nobel Physics winners?

18 hours ago

Two scientists will share the 2015 Nobel Prize in Physics, judges in Stockholm announced on Tuesday. But who are Takaaki Kajita and Arthur B McDonald?

Nobel Prizes 2015
BLOG: Sweden's Nobel Prize in Physics 2015
The Nobel Prize in Physics being announced in Stockholm. Photo: Fredrik Sandberg/TT

BLOG: Sweden's Nobel Prize in Physics 2015

22 hours ago

Scientists from Japan and Canada will share the 2015 Nobel Prize in Physics. The Local live blogged the key moments from Tuesday's announcement in Stockholm.

Housing 'crash' on cards warn top economists
A new apartment block in Barkarby, just outside Stockholm. Photo: Maja Suslin/TT

Housing 'crash' on cards warn top economists

1 day ago

Property prices have doubled in Sweden over the past ten years and the country’s National Institute of Economic Research (NIER) is warning that the market could soon end up crashing.

Nobel Medicine Laureates 2015
Sweden mourns Nordic Noir legend
Business & Money
Five essential tips for buying your first home in Sweden
Property of the week: Tumlehed, Gothenburg
How to never miss your favourite features on The Local
Blog updates

2 October

Editor’s blog, October 2nd (The Local Sweden) »

"Hi everyone, If you have been reading about Sweden in the international media this week, you would..." READ »


24 September

Checklist for your Swedish writing (The Swedish Teacher) »

"Hej hej! I thought I should share a checklist that I have made for my students. Enjoy! Spelling Did..." READ »

Analysis & Opinion
Why Sweden's 'six-hour day' is bogus
People-watching: October 2nd-4th
Sponsored Article
Stockholm International School: helping expat students feel at home
Swedes cash in on new bank notes
Meet the winners of Sweden's 'alternative Nobel' prize
Sponsored Article
Swedes 'know more about sex' than Brits
The secret to more travel for less
Rise in wolf attacks on animals in central Swedish town
Sponsored Article
11 reasons students pick Stockholm University
People-watching: September 30th
Sponsored Article
#LifeChangingOptions: Change lives with birth control
IN PICTURES: Sweden's new notes
How much do you know about Sweden's Cinnamon Bun Day?
DEBATE: Is joining a Swedish startup always worth the risk?
Why Sweden has launched sex books for disabled teens
Refugee protestors clash at Sweden's Lapland border
Property of the week: Mellby, Simrishamn
Sweden top for cancer survival rates
DEBATE: Can moving to Sweden make you more feminist?
IN PICTURES: What the supermoon looked like in Sweden
People-watching: September 25th-27th
Should empty jails be used to house refugees in Sweden?
Sponsored Article
Rugby in Scandinavia: an expat love story
jobs available
PSD Media
PSD Media is marketing company that offers innovative solutions for online retailers. We provide modern solutions that help increase traffic and raise conversion. Visit our site at: